9 ms·
That is more likely just a result of the people available to them for drawing/writing those ads, i.e. in non-English communities, rather than a willfully intend
by Razengan 10y ago
That is more likely just a result of the people available to them for drawing/writing those ads, i.e. in non-English communities, rather than a willfully intended effect.
Haven't you seen all the legit Chinese/Japanese/Indian/etc. ads in their home countries with spelling errors and "terrible graphics?" It's even somewhat of a meme [1] especially some of the stuff written on their t-shirts.
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/engrish https://www.reddit.com/r/engrish
- siegecraft 10y agoWhile I can't say for sure in this case, there are plenty of examples where ads are dumbed down because otherwise they don't appeal to the target market. Besides, if your target is dumb/gullible people, why take the risk of wasting a click on a smart person who you won't convert anyway?
- barrkel 10y agoAnecdata: once upon a time, I got into a conversation with the chap writing the sign outside a restaurant in Morocco, with the dishes of the day. With a smile on his face, he pointed out a spelling mistake on the sign: it was one he made deliberately, because he found (or believed) that more customers came in with the mistake than without. Less professional, more informal vibe? My whole trip to Morocco was very enlightening. The locals were extremely sharp WRT tourists and word got around surprisingly quickly. It's foolish to leap from an economy's development level to the intelligence or education of individuals within it. Economies usually suffer for more structural reasons.
- dasboth 10y ago"he found (or believed) that more customers came in with the mistake than without" I love this piece of (unintentional?) data-driven decision-making!
- blowski 10y agoI used to work for a price comparison website in the UK. After a big redesign which took them from being a horrendous mess to "glitzy web-2.0 style" (this was 2006) their conversion rates went down. They did some user research, and a lot of users said they trusted the site less after the redesign, because it now looked more like a typical advertising business.
- vocatus_gate 10y agoI worked for a sketchy MMO site back in the day (MMOEdge), and my friend who ran the site paid $20k for a very professional and slick-looking pre-built site from a team in Australia. It looked really good, much better than the old amateur-looking site that was currently running. But when he switched to it, he found conversion rates went down, by quite a bit actually. We couldn't figure it out and eventually switched back to the old "cheap" looking site, and traffic was restored. There's something about looking TOO professional that turns people away, I guess.
- 099182919 10y agoI find most "Web-2.0" websites childish and amateurish-looking. It's really a matter of taste. The Bloomberg site looks cheap to me -- just like a tabloid in the supermarket. It looked much more trustworthy a couple of years ago.
- fludlight 10y agoI felt the same way 10-15 years ago when the WSJ print edition started using color on the front page.
- jacquesm 10y agoI suspect that Craigslist would suffer the same way if they ever really changed. After all, that guy Craig whose list this is is not the same as some corporate slick entity and it makes it all look more genuine.
- vocatus_gate 10y agoMaybe it's that the semi-unprofessional look implies a personal connection, like it's just "that guy Craig" like you said, vs. an impersonal and polished corporation.
- roywiggins 10y agoI know I am much more willing to run some software downloaded from a website that looks like it hasn't changed since the late 90s and is maintained by one person and their dog.
- reitanqild 10y agoIIRC I have seen this discussed here on HN, someone had A/B tested their automated thanks-for-signing-up response mails "from the CEO" and found a significant improvemed response rate when they included one small speling mistake in the Subject.
- Domenic_S 10y ago> improvemed Are you A/B testing us?
- reitanqild 10y agoYou bwt :-)
- rahimnathwani 10y ago'speling mistake'?
- notahacker 10y agopretty sure that mailing list email body copy with the slightly awkward formatting a CEO might use for general correspondence will tend to outperform a neat obviously-a-mailshot-created-by-marketing HTML template when it comes to generating many types of response as well.
- ovt 10y agoPossibly it depends upon the audience. Another possibility is that someone makes an error and then claims it was intentional testing.
- komali2 10y agoI don't think the OP was commenting on the intelligence of the locals, but more their grasp of a foreign language. I've studied Chinese for six years and lived in Taiwan for four of them, I still make elementary mistakes because it's just not my native tongue. I bet if I was drawing up a menu I'd miss a couple characters or strokes on characters.
- markdown 10y ago> It's foolish to leap from an economy's development level to the intelligence or education of individuals within it. A relative of mine is the CEO of the Fiji branch of a major multinational B2B services company. Every few years, the regional headquarters in Australia would send over a guy from either Australia or New Zealand to manage some department. This would almost always end in disaster. The problem was that they would always end up insulting clients. Clients were multi-million dollar corporations, but since they were usually family run businesses, their founders/CEO's often spoke poor english. I guess this is what made these (white) men assume that they were idiots and end up talking down to them. The one time it worked was when the guy they sent was Aussie, but had been raised in Papua New Guinea. When this relative of mine became CEO, one of his first decisions was to ask HQ to send him a guy from their Sri Lanka office instead. It's been about five years now and they've had no more problems.
- walrus01 10y agoOn the flip side of this, white expat professionals sent to work in management roles for multinational companies in Pakistan and India will frequently find that their equivalently-ranked colleagues have better spelling and grammar than they do, having studied the Queen's English in elite private schools since kindergarten. The only major difference being pronunciation.
- walrus01 10y agoThere is a Greek food place on south 1st ave in Seattle that advertises "BEST YEEROS IN TOWN!" on their sign. Yes they know what a Gyro is and how it's really spelled.
- x0 10y agoI've heard it is common for many Chinese people, when eating at a Chinese restaurant in another country, choosing the cheapest looking restaurant, the restaurant with the most basic signage, shops that haven't changed much since the 1970's, etc. Reason being they expected the unpretentious and basic looking restaurants to be much more authentic.
- anexprogrammer 10y agoNot in the least surprising. I think it stems from something like... Too professional = corporate, paid scientists telling you tobacco is good for you, politician, used car salesman, style over substance. Less professional = honest craftsman, technician, artisan. It's more likely to be about the actual food than an empty brand experience. Of course there's also the chance they're just not very good, but it's probably not a bad generalisation. I'm sure there is research into this, but all I can find is blog opinions.
- tormeh 10y agoI read an interview with a woman in the industry. She was a native speaker and she had instructions to use spelling errors.
- heeen2 10y agoI read an interview with a professional designer of ads on porn sites (maybe in wired?), she said they are crappy and amateurish on purpose. I'd provide a source but this is not something I will google at work.
- mabbo 10y agoIt can actually work both ways. Imagine 100 new scammers start posting whatever they want on the internet. The ones who post with perfect English get lots of people replying, but most of the victims realize it's a scam quickly. The ones who post with bad English get fewer people replying, but those who do are the most likely to fall for the scam. You have a lovely Darwinian scenario here in which the highest return on investment comes from those with lower skill levels.