5 ms·
I hate screencasts. They force you to sit around watching, don't let you cut and paste or easily skim the content, and of course aren't like sitting next to so
by davidw 17y ago
I hate screencasts. They force you to sit around watching, don't let you cut and paste or easily skim the content, and of course aren't like sitting next to someone in that you can't stop the guy talking and ask him a question.
On the other hand, I'd love to see some good Rails articles.
- JeremyChase 17y agoScreencasts can be really annoying, and I prefer the asciicast versions of RyanB's casts. However, I still watch the videos, usually when I have some downtime and want to 'work' with someone else. For me, I do all my Rails dev solo, so all I have is vim, irc, and mailing lists. Screencasts are fun.
- hajrice 17y agoI agree. Screencasts are really fun, especially if the lecturer isn't boring and monotone!
- thibaut_barrere 17y agoI noticed something while talking with people on the subject - it's not only about the lecturer, at all. It's just a matter of taste: some people really hate screencasts, while other really love them (see on stackoverflow.com for debates on that topic!). You won't be able to please both (unless you have something similar to asciicasts maybe ?)
- hajrice 17y agoThanks to the power of mechanicalturk, I think I could pay them to transcript the videos.
- davidw 17y agoInteresting idea. I'd be curious to hear if they turn out a good transcript or whether their lack of understanding of the subject material makes it garbled. I guess with enough people doing it, you can check out the most common transcriptions and go with those...
- rubyrescue 17y agothat's how mixergy does it
- wvl 17y agoIf you are to do a truly high quality screencast, you would need to have a script (and code) written ahead of time anyway. Otherwise you would fall afoul of the other complaints in this thread -- overly long, rambling and unfocused.
- jmonegro 17y agoMost commercial screencasts ship with the source code. It's subjective, though, because many people are visual learners. For example, I had dabbled into jQuery through the docs and tutorials. However, it wasn't until I got a copy of Peepcode's jQuery screencast that I really got hold of it.
- hajrice 17y agoThat's interesting. Some people find it hard to learn by watching a screen cast. How much value do you see in these rails screencasts ?
- petercooper 17y agoI don't think videos are the best way to learn specifics, but in terms of seeing an overview or "connecting the dots" they work well. Ultimately, the real learning comes from the doing and by looking up stuff from various sources. To get the broad view and idea behind a topic, though, a well produced video can't be beaten. Given that, I doubt these screencasts would be that interesting if they went into every little detail - but if they gave the viewer enough confidence and interest to know what to look up elsewhere, it could work out well.
- csexton 17y agoScreencasts are one of the things that attracted me to Ruby in the first place. A few years ago I was debating between Ruby and few other languages and, to me, the best part of the language is the community around it. One part that separates it from others is the quality and variety of educational material. Well written articles, screencasts and podcasts are all consistently good. If you think screencasting will be fun -- go for it. If you put the time and effort into making a quality product I would watch it.
- Oompa 17y agoThis is why RailsCasts is awesome. Every article links to ASCIICasts, which has the exact same content, just written down.
- petercooper 17y agoWhile I prefer written content eventually, screencasts can be a great way to get the motivation and be forced to see the introductory stuff on a topic. A long article is easy to ignore but if you dedicate 10 minutes to a well produced screencast, it can certainly whet the appetite to go out and learn more.