3 ms·
You clearly are criticizing the theory. You state that there is an absence of intermediate forms, give an example of an intermediate between apes and chimpanzee
by mikeash 10y ago
You clearly are criticizing the theory. You state that there is an absence of intermediate forms, give an example of an intermediate between apes and chimpanzees, and conclude by stating that you'd expect a continuum. These aren't qualified with any of the humility you demand from others, they're just stated as bare "facts."
This is typical, though. State a bunch of nonsense, then when called on it say you're just asking questions, people shouldn't be so harsh, and would it kill evolutionists to be a little more humble?
It takes a lot more effort to refute bullshit than to spew it. People naturally and rightfully get frustrated when people spew it.
- barking 10y agoAre you sure that you actually read what i wrote?
- mikeash 10y agoQuite sure. What do you think I got wrong, exactly?
- barking 10y agoThe lack of intermediate species was something that i had thought was a big flaw in the theory of evolution. In my question, I don't think that I stated that as a fact but certainly suggested that I thought it was true. As a result of reading the answers on this thread and other internet readings I still believe that there is a lack of intermediate species but I no longer consider that to be evidence against evolution. If you consider my musings and questions as a bunch of nonsense and that I was stating them as facts and without humility, well I wouldn't agree with you.
- splawn 10y agoeverything alive falls into an "intermediate species" so, no, there is no lack of them.
- mikeash 10y agoYour concluding statement of "All the species seem very well defined when you'd expect a continuum." reads to me as an unqualified factual statement that happens to be quite wrong. (Depending on how you look at it, either the first or the second part is wrong.) That contrasted with the call for humility from people who actually understand this stuff really does not sound at all like "musings and questions" to me.
- barking 10y agoYou and I appear to ascribe very different meanings to the word 'seem'.