4 ms·
I think it is a good question. But where does the definition of species go when A can produce offspring with B, B can produce offspring with C but A cannot prod
by teekert 10y ago
I think it is a good question. But where does the definition of species go when A can produce offspring with B, B can produce offspring with C but A cannot produce offspring with C? Would you be willing to label B as an intermediate form?
Moreover, recognizing that the theory of evolution does not really speak of "intermediate forms" but of common ancestors, would you be willing to label an extinct (but well preserved in the fossil record, including its DNA) species that is the common ancestor of two species as an intermediate form?
In other words, what would be the evidence for evolution to convince you of the reality of the theory?
- barking 10y agoI am fairly convinced of its veracity as it is. I would just like to see more and more evidence as time goes by. Physicists (and I'm not one of those either) seem to have a completely different attitude to evolution scientists. Recently more evidence in support of einstein's relativity theory has been found, I believe. But they are still completely open to binning the theory if contradictory evidence appears. There just seems to be an almost religious fervour around evolution that seems a bit unhealthy
- splawn 10y agoI agree that religious fervor of any kind is unhealthy... However evidence will always crowd out the possibility of "religious fervor". Biologists are just as open to changing their model as Physicists are they just need a reason to do so. All evidence points to evolution. You can find it in the geologic record as well as markers in every living organism's DNA. Speaking of DNA... evolution predicted its existence and mechanisms well before its discovery. Im not sure where your confusion stems from... religious fervor perhaps?
- barking 10y agoYes I am sure evidence will win out in the end regardless.
- splawn 10y agoConsidering we are 200 years in and have proceeded to continually make discoveries in Biology to the point of engineering technologies that drastically extend our life spans... All without finding anything contrary to natural selection. I would say evidence as far as this topic is concerned has already won out.