3 ms·
> The black moths could still mate with the peppered variety so they're still the same species just different 'breeds', perhaps, so is this really evolution? I
by Angostura 10y ago
> The black moths could still mate with the peppered variety so they're still the same species just different 'breeds', perhaps, so is this really evolution?
It absolutely is evolution, what it isn't is 'speciation'. For speciation to occur you would have to have enough reproductive isolation and enough time to allow for sufficient change - let's say in the range of thousands/millions of years, rather than a decade or two. Biologists will tell you anyway that the concept of a biological species is a bit hard to pin down anyway.
I don't quite understand your criticism regarding intermediate forms. There are many clusters of species where interbreeding is possible to some extent - Zeedonks, Ligers et all, not mention types of bluebell, dandelions etc. Moreover there are many many species where there are distinct varieties which are still similar enough to interbreed, but may be on their way to separating if given enough time and isolation.
- lanna 10y ago> There are many clusters of species where interbreeding is possible to some extent Do not forget that the offspring itself also has to be fertile. Most hybrids aren't.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- roywiggins 10y agoSpeciation can occur more or less immediately if two species produce a successful hybrid. It's much more common in plants, but it happens in animals too. The idea is, you have two species that occasionally produce viable offspring, which are themselves reproductively isolated from their own parent species. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybrid_speciation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybrid_speciation