5 ms·
There has been too much recently of government agencies losing data due to "crashes" or "inadvertent" deletions. For example the IRS, state department, and now
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y ago
There has been too much recently of government agencies losing data due to "crashes" or "inadvertent" deletions. For example the IRS, state department, and now the Air Force.
A really easy way to fix this is to make a law so that if government data such as this gets lost, then the cabinet level person responsible for overseeing the agency immediately loses their cabinet level position and is barred from further work with the federal government.
This would do wonders to align incentives all through the federal agencies when it comes to data safeguards.
- sverige 10y agoYeah, forgive me if I'm too cynical, but Hanlon's razor fails when this sort of thing involves criminal investigations of government employees. Edit: it also inspired a variation on an old joke about how the same word means different things to different people. For example, suppose the order goes out to "secure the data center." Marines report back, "We have destroyed the data center." Army reports, "We have killed everyone in the data center and are holding the position." Navy: "We locked the doors when we left for the day." Air Force: "We signed a three-year contract with an outsourcing company, with an option to extend at the same price for ten more years." Which of course means that just because I don't think Hanlon's razor applies doesn't mean I think they're competent.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jMyles 10y ago> Yeah, forgive me if I'm too cynical, but Hanlon's razor fails when this sort of thing involves criminal investigations of government employees. I've had this thought before. Can you think of a general, defensible clause to add to Hanlon's razor to account for this?
- thaumasiotes 10y ago"There is no point in trying to distinguish incompetence from malice when it directly benefits the party committing the error." You need to treat it all as malice.
- jMyles 10y agoThis seems like a very reasonable standard when the power of the state is being wielded.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoIt applies at all times. Given that it's very easy to disguise your behavior as incompetence, it doesn't make sense to give the benefit of the doubt to people who do something that gives them a huge payout. Trying to forgive the incompetent people while punishing the malicious ones just brings you a huge epidemic of mysteriously incompetent people.
- jMyles 10y agoBut what if it's not about punishment, but prevention?
- sverige 10y ago"Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by carelessness." Unless that malice is aimed at keeping an individual out of trouble rather than harming others.
- pfortuny 10y agoIt only applies to physical persons, not to groups.
- Bartweiss 10y agoThe usual formulation I hear is: "Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity. But don't rule out malice."
- jaytaylor 10y agoThis seems like a great idea for incentivizing success. I'd support such legislation 100%.
- heimatau 10y agoThis idea is too simplistic. Although I used to support it. I've changed my position from yours to 'retrained and demotion' position. Since people make mistakes, I think being 'barred from further work' is counter-productive and the government would lose out on many able and competent workers. Heck, this idea could also be exploited by lower-level workers due to not liking their higher-up bosses; i.e. a lower-level worker intentionally screwing up and costing the job of the higher-up boss because of the 'new law' stating the higher-up is now 'barred' from further govt work. Easy way to take out the competition going up a ladder. P.S. I think legislating accountability is an issue the public needs to debate. In all countries. The US has seen numerous gross negligence/errors (heck one is too many) in various levels of govt (fed, state, local). I hope we can come up with a better solution than 'fire them and bar them' and even mine of 'demote/retrain'. There has to be a better way to legislate govt accountability.
- PakG1 10y agoIndeed, such ideas would create an atmosphere of fear and increase cover-ups, rather than solve problems. There needs to be a solution that acknowledges the inevitably of mistakes and still deals with the issue.
- iamflimflam1 10y agoExactly this. How many of us would be up in arms if developers were fired for making mistakes? You just need to look at all the stories around rm -rf...
- tmptmp 10y agoso what if tomorrow your bank says it has lost all records due to programming/tech error? who is responsible there? why is such sensitive data (air force etc) should be treated differently than cash/finance data?
- emp_zealoth 10y agoMaybe thats exactly what should happen? I mean, whole "security" antics where companies loose tens of millions of logins/credit cards numbers and it all ends with "southpark BP apology" People fuck up epically and get a slap on a wrist with a promotion, I mean, come on
- picklebutt 10y agoIt's super convient considering congress is investigating their discipline processes after some incidents they've had.
- laughfactory 10y agoI agree. These days I don't believe it when I hear something so opportune... oh, surprise surprise, we lost all our data on criminal investigations. How convenient for some people!
- tn13 10y agoCan not agree more. Losing data must be considered a same level of crime as losing money or life.
- varjag 10y agoAll that would lead to is make any process change in the government impossible, domination of defensive document workflow a.k.a. CYA, and thorough lack of leadership.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoImagine what would happen in the industry if every time someone screwed up like that they got fired. Just like that, without any option given to explain what happened, how they tried everything they could from stopping it and so on. Ah, I know it's the way it is in some organisations, sure. But is it a good way to handle people screwing up? People always screw up. If you start firing them for screwing up you end up with a pool of inexperienced workers who keep screwing up in the same way. If you keep them around, they learn and never screw up in the same way again.
- saiya-jin 10y agothere is screwing up and screwing up. one - you do all you could, act proactively, educate yourself, but forces beyond your control prevent you from reaching optimal state and massive clusterfk happens. I would keep this one. then you have ignorants, that in 2016 will not even think that mission-critical system should have SOME backup, off-site. people that will put amazing amount of energy into little political games, backstabbing, or just plain old incompetent lazy ones. those should become exemplary cases. investigation should sort out which is which, but most will fall on either side of spectrum. usually it's really not that hard.
- keithpeter 10y ago"Neither the Air Force nor Lockheed Martin, the defense firm that runs the database, could say why it became corrupted or whether they’ll be able to recover the information." Incumbent trusts local IT manager and local IT manager has contract with external company. The question becomes: "Did the contract with Lockheed Martin cover any form of regular backup and additionally some form of long term open format archiving?" Perhaps some checklists or standards that all long term record keeping systems need to comply with would be good.
- seanwilson 10y agoMaking mistakes is an important part of learning and becoming experienced. I'm sure we've all done a bad "rm -f" from time and time, and each mistakes makes you more cautious in the future.
- WalterBright 10y agoIt's always an attractive idea to eliminate incompetence through threats. It's been tried lots of times throughout history, and has never succeeded (in fact, it usually makes things worse).
- madaxe_again 10y agoLosing their position is meaningless - they'll just go private and make even more money while being recklessly incompetent. They'd just hire a clean agent as their intermediary for government contracts. No, I'd slap prison sentences on everyone involved, not just loss of government employment.
- gravypod 10y ago> A really easy way to fix this is to make a law so that if government data such as this gets lost, then the cabinet level person responsible for overseeing the agency immediately loses their cabinet level position and is barred from further work with the federal government. I see a fantastic way to completely abuse this. Need to get someone who disagrees with you kicked out? Hire some corporate espionage people to take care of that work for you!