3 ms·
It's quite telling that this attempt by a Marxist government to computerise control of the economy had it's biggest success in organising scabs during a strike.
by mseebach 17y ago
It's quite telling that this attempt by a Marxist government to computerise control of the economy had it's biggest success in organising scabs during a strike.
Also..
It took about a year to become operational but it was never completely finished.
and
The software (...) was written by Chilean engineers in consultation with a team of 12 British programmers.
12 developers for a year.. controlling the entire economy?This smells a lot like vaporware, and it was in fact never operational, even though the article makes it sound like the main culprit was the 1973 coup.
- scotty79 17y agoIt was just 500 factories. Probably any company today that has at least 500 factories has similar (modern) hierarchical system of control in place. AI is effectively replacing free market from inside out not top down like in government attempts to instantiate centrally planned economy.
- gritzko 17y agoExactly. Free market does not contradict planning. Both in-house and national-level planning works quite nicely in market economies. Leontief got a Nobel for theory and practice of the process.
- nfnaaron 17y ago"Probably any company today that has at least 500 factories has similar (modern) hierarchical system of control in place." Yeah, it's called Walmart.
- andrewcooke 17y agoa little historical context: that strike was funded by the cia... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salvador_Allende#US_involvement http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salvador_Allende#US_involvement
- andr 17y agoThe hard part of such as system is defining the objectives and the economical model to use, but that work is left to politicians, not programmers. Once the model is known, it is much simpler to write a program which applies it to get from the current situation to the objective. 1 year sounds perfectly reasonable.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoYes, the technical aspects of network communication are relatively trivial. The actual economic planning absurdly difficult -- impossible, in fact. Friedrich Hayek showed (and won a Nobel Prize for his work) that the coordination of production in the economy is achieved by using money as the channel of communication, which neatly encapsulates all of the information about preferences, substitutability, etc. Planned economies are necessarily subject to shortages and the like because it's impossible for any centralized entity to have all the knowledge about what the goals and needs of all actors are. The article argues against the establishment of a Central Pricing Board (advocated by Lange) by highlighting the assiduously dynamic and organic nature of market price-fluctuations, and the benefits of this phenomenon. He asserts that a centrally planned market could never match the efficiency of the open market because any individual knows only a small fraction of all which is known collectively. A decentralized economy thus complements the dispersed nature of information spread throughout society. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Use_of_Knowledge_in_Society http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Use_of_Knowledge_in_Society