5 ms·

Actually everyone should be free from being criticized, except for the people with the authority to do so. That goes double for people doing hard work and tripl

Actually everyone should be free from being criticized, except for the people with the authority to do so. That goes double for people doing hard work and triple for people doing work that every joe shmoe on the internet thinks himself an expert on. In other words, my spouse can criticize my parenting everyone else can go frack themselves. Full stop.

dimino 10y ago
No one is free from criticism, what they're free from is being forced to listen to it. No one's making anyone else here participate in the discussion. Performing hard work doesn't make you immune from doing that work poorly, and it's kind of alarming to me that this insular attitude is so popular on HN.
- gh-lfneu28 10y ago
  > they're free from is being forced to listen to it That's what I've called 'free from being critisized' so yeah. Not sure what you mean by "No one is free from criticism". If you refer to rights of other people to express their critical opinion - sure, let them run their mouths in their own space. The problems begin (as usual) when A is being forced to listen to B's opinions either because A cannot move away or because Bs are too numerous. That's where I think that B should have to shut up. "Your freedom to fo X ends etc etc". Participating in hard work is an aggravating factor here, meaning B should have to shut the f up right now or be forcefully removed. In case of doubt just imaging an idiot shouting their mouth at the working surgeon.
  - dimino 10y ago
    Sorry, numerousness or locality are not criteria for removing a person's right to expression. A needs to learn to tolerate B, basically. A isn't performing surgery, A is trying to write comments on HN.
    - gh-lfneu28 10y ago
      > A is trying to write comments on HN Huh? The topic was about people doing hard work. Writing comments is easy.
      - dimino 10y ago
        The topic was McDonald's being used as community centers in poor neighborhoods.

dimino 10y ago

No one is free from criticism, what they're free from is being forced to listen to it. No one's making anyone else here participate in the discussion. Performing hard work doesn't make you immune from doing that work poorly, and it's kind of alarming to me that this insular attitude is so popular on HN.

gh-lfneu28 10y ago
> they're free from is being forced to listen to it That's what I've called 'free from being critisized' so yeah. Not sure what you mean by "No one is free from criticism". If you refer to rights of other people to express their critical opinion - sure, let them run their mouths in their own space. The problems begin (as usual) when A is being forced to listen to B's opinions either because A cannot move away or because Bs are too numerous. That's where I think that B should have to shut up. "Your freedom to fo X ends etc etc". Participating in hard work is an aggravating factor here, meaning B should have to shut the f up right now or be forcefully removed. In case of doubt just imaging an idiot shouting their mouth at the working surgeon.
- dimino 10y ago
  Sorry, numerousness or locality are not criteria for removing a person's right to expression. A needs to learn to tolerate B, basically. A isn't performing surgery, A is trying to write comments on HN.
  - gh-lfneu28 10y ago
    > A is trying to write comments on HN Huh? The topic was about people doing hard work. Writing comments is easy.
    - dimino 10y ago
      The topic was McDonald's being used as community centers in poor neighborhoods.