11 ms·
Can someone explain what this means? The term "net neutrality" has been muddled so much that I can't tell if it means what it actually says, or if it's distorte
by StavrosK 10y ago
Can someone explain what this means? The term "net neutrality" has been muddled so much that I can't tell if it means what it actually says, or if it's distorted doublespeak that actually means the opposite.
Is this decision good or bad for us?
- theseanstewart 10y agoThis is very good. It means Net Neutrality is here to stay (for now).
- wmeredith 10y agoThis is the core of what was upheld: "No Blocking: broadband providers may not block access to legal content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices. "No Throttling: broadband providers may not impair or degrade lawful Internet traffic on the basis of content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices. "No Paid Prioritization: broadband providers may not favor some lawful Internet traffic over other lawful traffic in exchange for consideration of any kind—in other words, no "fast lanes." This rule also bans ISPs from prioritizing content and services of their affiliates." This is a good thing. Big telcos have been trying to gut the FCC of its power ever since they issued their Open Internet Order: https://www.fcc.gov/general/open-internet https://www.fcc.gov/general/open-internet Next stop is the supreme court if they continue to push back against it.
- komali2 10y agoDoes this mean netflix can stop paying Comcast?
- nikanj 10y agoProbably not, as Netflix has no way to prove Comcast is throttling them and the FCC is toothless
- inanutshellus 10y agoIs this ruling not the FCC regaining "teeth"?
- rkangel 10y agoNo, this is validation that the FCCs position is legal. Nor they need a mechanism to enforce it properly. That doesn't just mean the ability to impose penalties (which is part of it) but also means the power to know what's going on so that penalties can be imposed.
- dragonwriter 10y agoThe FCC has existing complaint-based, investigatory, and other enforcement mechanisms, which have been around for a long time, and have been available to use (e.g., complaints have been accepted) under the Open Internet Order since it was issued (heck, they've had successful enforcement actions under the part of the old [2010] Open Internet Order -- the transparency rule -- that weren't struck down in Verizon v. FCC, such as the $100M penalty against AT&T Mobility for misrepresenting its "unlimited" plans.) What do you imagine it doesn't have that it needs with regard to the Open Internet Order in this area?
- cmdrfred 10y agoOn paper you are correct, but I doubt the person who runs the FCC gets to golf with the president[0][1]. [0]http://www.politico.com/blogs/media/2013/08/obama-golfs-with-comcast-ceo-170524 http://www.politico.com/blogs/media/2013/08/obama-golfs-with... [1]http://www.nationalreview.com/article/375116/how-comcast-bought-democratic-party-matthew-continetti http://www.nationalreview.com/article/375116/how-comcast-bou...
- pdabbadabba 10y agoThat's a pretty ironic view. This all got started when the FCC ordered Comcast to stop blocking file-sharing services like BitTorrent. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/08/01/AR2008080101205.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/08... Comcast sued and the FCC spent the next eight years fighting.
- dimino 10y agoThere's a difference between "not throttling" and "allowing a peering agreement". This ruling doesn't mean Comcast must allow Netflix to put servers in Comcast's datacenters. Peering agreements have never really been part of a truly "neutral" Internet.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> There's a difference between "not throttling" and "allowing a peering agreement". There basically isn't. Otherwise they just underprovision the default link so that anything using it is de facto throttled and the only alternative is peering. > This ruling doesn't mean Comcast must allow Netflix to put servers in Comcast's datacenters. Peering doesn't require putting servers in your datacenter. Peering means Netflix brings fiber to Comcast's datacenter and Comcast plugs it into one of their network ports.
- rhino369 10y agoThere is a big difference. Peering isn't the only way to deliver packets. There probably should be some regulation of ISP peering but it just doesn't fall under net neutrality. If anything it's sort of against net neutrality. A small startup would have pay for a CDN or a transit and netflix gets it for free? Just because they are big.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> If anything it's sort of against net neutrality. A small startup would have pay for a CDN or a transit and netflix gets it for free? Just because they are big. They don't get anything for free that the little guy doesn't. They're just doing their own transit instead of paying somebody else to do it. Nobody is saying Netflix can peer with Comcast in California for Comcast customers in New England. They have to bring the traffic into the region, whether by paying someone for transit or by building their own transit network. Comcast just can't charge them for access to the last mile, and neither can it charge anybody else (like the transit providers who provide service to the little guy).
- 10y ago
- vermontdevil 10y agoI doubt the Supreme Court will pick this up until the ninth seat is filled.
- rincebrain 10y agoI don't think they're going to put everything on hold until that seat is filled; if nothing else, the lack of movement toward confirming or denying a nominee means that they would become grossly backlogged by doing so.
- dragonwriter 10y agoThere are very few cases where Supreme Court action is mandatory; the Supreme Court choosing not to take cases won't result in them being backlogged, it will result in lower court decisions being let stand (forming only local, rather than national, authoritative precedent) because the Supreme Court choose not to hear appeals.
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoAdditionally, a 4-4 vote has exactly the same result as them not taking up the case at all, so it is really just a waste of time for them to take up cases that are expected to result in a 4-4 vote.
- coldpie 10y agoSo, never?
- vermontdevil 10y agoNo. Not never. Just some cases will be punted a bit further down the road. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2016/06/02/the-supreme-court-is-taking-far-fewer-cases-than-usual-heres-why/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2016/06/0... Maybe I'm wrong but we'll see.
- criddell 10y agoSo can broadband providers still strike zero-rating deals with companies like Spotify?
- dragonwriter 10y agoAs the article notes, zero-rating is not covered by the Open Internet order; its an area that the FCC is actively working on but has not issued any orders related to, yet.
- criddell 10y agoYikes! Don't know how I missed that. Thanks.
- anf 10y agoIs zero-rating pertinent outside of metered mobile bandwidth?
- dragonwriter 10y agoIt only makes any sense in a metered or capped plan, and its currently only an issue in metered mobile plans (although it could in principal also be used with capped fixed-location plans, as well.)
- mordocai 10y agoAccording to the article, it looks like it.
- tzs 10y ago> Next stop is the supreme court if they continue to push back against it More likely the next stop is Congress. Reversing basically everything the FCC has done with the internet and making sure the FCC does not do any such things again is a major goal of the Republicans and they currently have majorities in the House and the Senate. Their presumptive presidential nominee, Trump, is also against net neutrality, seeing it as a liberal attack on conservatives: "Obama’s attack on the internet is another top down power grab. Net neutrality is the Fairness Doctrine. Will target conservative media" [1]. [1] https://twitter.com/realdonaldtrump/status/532608358508167168?lang=en https://twitter.com/realdonaldtrump/status/53260835850816716...
- dragonwriter 10y ago> More likely the next stop is Congress. Well, if by "next" you mean "previous, current, next, and always"; Republicans in the Congress have been pushing to explicitly prohibit FCC Open Internet action since before the 2010 Open Internet Report and Order. The only thing they've gone after more has been the Affordable Care Act. But that's a different track than the legal challenges, which have been the only place where neutrality opponents have had concrete victories in the past.
- st3v3r 10y agoI can understand why Republicans don't like net neutrality. I cannot fathom at all the argument made by Trump that a law requiring equal access to both liberal and conservative media, not to mention everything in between and outside, is going to "target conservative media". Is he saying that if people have equal access to all, that they will reject conservative media?
- rashkov 10y agoYou're mistaken if you think that trump is presenting any kind of rational argument. Instead he is appealing to his voter base, many of whom feel that the mainstream media and Silicon Valley companies are silencing conservative viewpoints. See search terms: "Google biased towards Hillary", "Facebook censoring conservative news", "conservative msm", "conservative lamestream media".
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> "No Paid Prioritization: broadband providers may not favor some lawful Internet traffic over other lawful traffic in exchange for consideration of any kind—in other words, no "fast lanes." This rule also bans ISPs from prioritizing content and services of their affiliates." In the absence of a clear definition of "favor", this could also make it difficult for ISPs to host CDNs, or caching servers provided by content providers. If you put Netflix's caching box on your network, in some sense that "favors" Netflix traffic. And yet doing so is good for Netflix, the ISP, and the customer.
- wrsh07 10y agoIf it's good for the ISP, then Netflix shouldn't have to pay for it, which would make it okay, right?
- JoshTriplett 10y ago"consideration of any kind" would likely include giving the ISP a free server. For that matter, there's nothing wrong with a CDN giving an ISP money to host a server on their network, if the balance of costs between the CDN and the ISP works out that way. An early-stage CDN or site-specific CDN might well have to do that to get started.
- snowwrestler 10y agoAn ISP hosting edge caching servers shouldn't violate the rule so long as: a) The ISP's own systems do not discriminate for or against the traffic from that edge server (i.e. no rules on Comcast's routers to slow down netflix.com while speeding up nbc.com). b) The ISP offers the same edge server hosting deal to anyone who wants it. Big ISPs now own content companies, so even if they don't lease space to Netflix, they would still have edge caching servers on their networks--their own. The neutrality rule seeks to ensure that they don't shape their network traffic to degrade content from other providers who don't own the wires and routers.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoIn general it means no blocking or throttling by a certain class of ISP. I believe mobile gets an exception as they are allowed to non-discriminatory throttle past a certain "data cap." This includes lower caps for mobile hotspot usage. Also, T-Mobile is arguably violating non-netrality with its Binge service. The FCC has thus far refused to rule against them. T-Mobile claims this cannot be throttling because you can opt-out of it at any time and upstream providers are not being charged. Seems like this could a slippery slope for wired ISPs to follow. On top of that, I'm a AT&T u-verse customer who recently cut his TV service with U-verse. I was told that I now have a strict data cap, when before I had unlimited because of that. I would like to see the FCC address these situations as cord-cutting becomes popular. I have a FireTV now with Playstation Vue and HBO Now for at least 1/2 the price of U-verse tv.
- oconnore 10y agoThe most important part of the decision is granting the FCC authority to consider internet providers as a utility -- and therefore regulate their activities in the interest of the consumer. The actual "net neutrality" win is nice, but this means that the FCC has power to tweak the regulations in the future when Verizon/Comcast/AT&T come up with some new shitty way to monetize their customers.
- mtgx 10y agoNet neutrality is "good" in the sense that it has some regulations that "should" stop the carriers from making the Internet much worse than it already is - with the caveat that the FCC actually enforces those rules, and so far it hasn't (maybe it was just waiting for the Court to uphold these rules - we'll see). But these net neutrality rules won't really make the Internet "better" in the U.S., until the ISPs get much better competition, mainly at the local level. Right now this is often not possible because of "other regulations" that essentially give exclusive rights/monopoly to an ISP over a certain area. If you want "better Internet", eliminating those local monopolies should be the main goal for policy changes going forward. It's something Republicans should vigorously support as well (free market!), but for some reason (read: campaign donations) they do not.
- gm-conspiracy 10y agoBefore rayiner replies to this and insists it is not a monopoly, but a "non-exclusive franchise agreement", I give you this link: Cable TV Franchises as Barriers to Video Competition http://www.vjolt.net/vol12/issue1/v12i1_a2-Hazlett.pdf http://www.vjolt.net/vol12/issue1/v12i1_a2-Hazlett.pdf
- textdog 10y agoIt also means no government or telecom company (or corporation for that matter) can get in between you and the Internet content of your choosing through sneaky slowing down or throttling.
- dclowd9901 10y agoThe only thing you need to know is that telcos and providers are against net neutrality. (Ok, so some people on here would argue that any regulation on internet is a slippery slope, but I wouldn't worry about that from the FCC. Now, if congress starts weighing in, that's a different story.)
- sideband 10y agoThis is probably an unpopular opinion, but I believe it's a net negative. Typically, ISPs in the US are either small and barely-profitable or large and with little appetite for business or technical innovation. The largest content providers already effectively share revenue with the largest ISPs through paid-peering and other arrangements. The smaller players, those that with success could grow and advance the market, are too small to justify the time of content providers that are also very worried about setting a dangerous precedent by extending the same deals to them that they extend to the AT&Ts and Comcasts. Sure, as consumers we get additional protections, but I fear this mostly ensures that the industry as a whole stays put.
- baldfat 10y ago> I fear this mostly ensures that the industry as a whole stays put. That was 100% the point of Net Neutrality. It is so that the Internet doesn't change. Otherwise we will have a barrier of entry for all the small businesses. The Internet is a free market that needs to stay that way.
- ZenoArrow 10y agoSorry, I don't understand your point. The whole idea of net neutrality is that content creators can't pay ISPs for preferential treatment. This means that the large ISPs won't be receiving payouts from Netflix and suchlike, and therefore won't have an advantage in this area over smaller ISPs. If you really want to push for competition, there are other options. I don't know much about the situation in the US, but in the UK we have local-loop unbundling (LLU), which has proven to be a success in driving forward competition in the ISP market. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local-loop_unbundling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local-loop_unbundling LLU helps smaller ISPs to compete with larger ISPs, as it allows them to build up their infrastructure without duplicating the work of laying cables. From the Wikipedia page I just linked to it appears that LLU is at least legal in the US, I'd be interested to learn about how popular it is.
- sideband 10y agoMy point in less words: The big guys (ISPs and content providers) all share revenue already and will continue to. This ruling shuts the little guys out of that action forever under the guise of consumer interest, rendering them permanently less competitive. That's bad.
- don_draper 10y agoNet Neutrality means the Internet should be treated as a utility and not a luxury.