5 ms·
I'm guessing this is a not-so-subtle critique of GMO labeling. I'm not against GMOs, but anyone who is against labeling is caught up by propaganda. Everything
by colordrops 10y ago
I'm guessing this is a not-so-subtle critique of GMO labeling. I'm not against GMOs, but anyone who is against labeling is caught up by propaganda. Everything else that goes into food is labeled - there is nothing wrong with mentioning that a food contains GMO as well.
- sdoering 10y agoI am with you. But sadly (at least in Germany and the EU) not everything is labeled. For example if a juice is filtered using gelatin there is no need to label this, even if the possibility exists, that residuals still remain in the juice. Just to name one example. We also have no "need"/regulation for labeling of some ingredients, that were contained in the initial ingredients (and were useful there) but are not needed for the end-product and have no influence on the end product. As an example take stuff needed to make curd. Has to be in the label for curd, but if you use curd in a product and the stuff needed to make curb has no influence on the end-product there is no need for labeling. So a lot of stuff get omitted without a full declaration. And food lobby does everything to prevent full declaration from happening. Nobody really wants informed customers.
- ptaipale 10y agoThe problem is, when you make all sorts of labeling mandatory, any meaning is lost. Gelatin residuals have no health impacts. DNA or GM residuals have no health impact. You fill the packaging with unnecessary labels, and then the actually relevant things - like how much sugar something contains - are obscured. This is similar to the over-cautious safety warnings that nowadays clutter all user instructions of devices and tools. It should be left to user discretion whether to wear safety goggles when you use a hammer to hit a nail, for instance. Even if there is a one-in-a-million chance that a spark flies off and hits your eye.
- barrkel 10y agoThe reason for labelling isn't just for health impact, though. It's also about being a responsible consumer. If you don't see what went into making a product, you can't use your purchase decision to vote on how you'd like the supply chain to be aligned. Personally I'm against the over-industrialization of the food supply. Industry wants consistent predictable products it can mass-produce; that's explicitly what I don't want. I don't want every tomato to taste exactly the same, year in year out, everywhere around the world. I want more diversity.
- ptaipale 10y agoThat is a reasonable enough desire, but why make others do mandatory labeling to meet your requirements? The law should be the minimum requirement for health and environmental concerns, and if there's value in consumer choice on ethical grounds (such as that you want to avoid GM food, or want to have halal meat) that labeling can be left to the discretion of the manufacturer/provider/seller. Personally, I often try to avoid food labeled as "organic" (that being responsible for the most lethal food disaster in recent years, 50 people dead in Germany). Still, I don't want that it would be mandatory to label organic food as such.
- barrkel 10y agoThe single biggest moral problem with capitalism is that it relies too much on price to transmit information. If your decision to buy something comes down to evaluating its value to you, comparing that with the price, and purchasing it if it is both more valuable to you than the price and relatively better than the alternatives, then you're not acting morally. Inputs to products, like slavery, child labour, undemocratic governments right through to irresponsible use of antibiotics, are all obscured under this basis. In order to get pricing to have an impact on how products are made and inputs are chosen, the consumer needs to be informed. But the need for the consumer to be informed is in direct opposition to the interests of the producer: the producer wants to remove reasons for the consumer to reject the product. And this runs right along the supply chain to raw materials. If the consumer doesn't have information on how something is produced, and no alternatives are available with more information, how can they make their purchasing decision affect the whole supply chain? And let's not forget how pleasant it is to be unknowingly complicit in illegal or immoral actions that benefit you by price; what you don't know doesn't make you feel guilty. You got the product cheaply, do you really want to know why it was so cheap? Consumer psychology is part of the problem too: relying solely on pricing for information lets people get away with murder, indirectly. Thus I think mandatory labelling throughout the supply chain is absolutely vital for moral capitalism. People need to know to what extent their purchasing decisions are indirectly funding oppression and harm elsewhere.
- mkesper 10y ago
- coredog64 10y agoWARNING: This product contains chemicals known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm.
- goodcanadian 10y agoFor those unfamiliar, this label is EVERYWHERE. It was on my car; it was at the coffee shop; it was at the entrance to my job. EVERYWHERE to the point of meaninglessness.
- VLM 10y ago>Gelatin residuals have no health impacts. There are religious issues. There are no non-animal sources of gelatin, so that is an issue for vegans or vegetarians. I have absolutely no idea if gelatin used for juice filtering is kosher or halal. There do exist somewhat more expensive sources of vegetable based biopolymers that are superficially somewhat gelatin like, or there are other technologies to filter juice or whatever, but if none of it is going to be labeled anyway...
- unclenoriega 10y agoIt seems to me there's room to have mandated, policed labeling for certain things (e.g. common allergens, calories, certain nutrients) and voluntary, tort-enforced labeling for more moral or religious concerns. That seems reasonable, but maybe I'm missing some practical problems. Evidenced by this comment section, one issue could be categorizing certain things like GMO and antibiotic use.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoLet's also have indicators for whether the food is pro- or anti-abortion. :D
- colordrops 10y agoThat is a non-sequitur.
- Houshalter 10y agoYou can label foods that are GMO free if you are catering to the small minority of people that care. Labeling all foods that contain GMOs is just silly and wasteful. And it implies something is wrong with the product or that they could be unsafe. It doesn't make any more sense than labeling everything that contains DNA. Which as this article states, most consumers would prefer. And many think it is unsafe, and would avoid such foods!
- colordrops 10y agoNo. Aspartame and Sodium Benzoate have been scientifically tested to be generally safe, but they must be listed on the label. No two genetic modifications are the same, and aren't all just inherently safe. They are safe because each one has been tested. You are making a logical error when you compare genetic modifications to DNA. DNA is just four amino acids, and the arrangement doesn't change the nutritional content. What if you made a GMO apple with no sugar that contained aspartame. Should that not be labeled? Different genetic modifications can produce different results, from increasing vitamins to creating toxins. It's NOT the same.
- bobcostas55 10y agoLabeling is not free. There is something wrong with spending massive amounts of money on something of no importance.
- colordrops 10y ago> something of no importance With a single swipe of your hand and no reasoning behind it, you ignore the fact that a large portion of society considers it to be important.
- Jarwain 10y agoI don't have any issues with GMO labeling, so long as said labels describe the modification(s) that have been made. This is a lot more useful in helping a consumer make an informed decision
- viggity 10y agoGMO Activists... Now: "If GMO's are so safe, then why are you afraid of labeling them?" After labels become required: "If GMOs are so safe, then why do they need warning labels?"
- collyw 10y agoThey complained about cross contamination. Along comes the terminator gene, and they complain about not being able to make seeds.
- viggity 10y agoThe "terminator" gene effects hybrid seed. Seeds you would never want to plant anyway because they have shit performance. Terminator gene (similar to male or female sterility genes) simply make hybrid seeds cheaper to produce. You don't have to pay armies of teenagers to detassel the 4-5 rows of female plants and you don't need to mow your 1 row of male plants.
- colordrops 10y agoThis is a straw man. No one said "warning" label. I said "label", just like ingredients are labeled.