4 ms·
I understand your original point (if I still don't agree entirely), I was addressing some topics you brought up as tangents. I understand a language will alway
by kbenson 10y ago
I understand your original point (if I still don't agree entirely), I was addressing some topics you brought up as tangents. I understand a language will always develop external tools is used enough, but I don't think that precludes migrating tools that have proved themselves into a language if the trade-off is clearly a good one, or at least a good one for a subset of problems (I think Rust fits this description).
To take a different tack on why I think it's not a waste to focus on rewrites of well established, mature code bases, consider the following: Rust is young. There aren't a lot of projects out there using it (comparatively), and almost none in certain sub-areas where it is supposedly a good fit (low level systems programs). A good way to find pitfalls, develop best practices and idioms, and find the pain points of the language is to use it to reimplement a well known, mature, stable project and see how it turns out.
You can say "sure, but we shouldn't focus on just that!", which is true, but also a non-sequitur, as I'm not sure anyone is actually doing so, or even suggesting it be done exclusively that way. I know what you are arguing, I'm just not sure why you feel the need to argue it, since I don't see anyone actually holding a position opposite you (the "we need to rebuild every project in Rust" view).
- pron 10y ago> but I don't think that precludes migrating tools that have proved themselves into a language if the trade-off is clearly a good one, or at least a good one for a subset of problems Sure. > A good way to find pitfalls, develop best practices and idioms, and find the pain points of the language is to use it to reimplement a well known, mature, stable project and see how it turns out. Sure. I said that if the goal is to experiment with Rust, then rewriting some old code is a good exercise. But if the goal is to improve the quality of ~50MLOC, there are cheaper, less risky approaches.