7 ms·
> Soviet Adm. Sergei Gorchakov reportedly held the view that the U.S. had made a strategic miscalculation by relying on large and increasingly vulnerable aircra
by rdtsc 10y ago
> Soviet Adm. Sergei Gorchakov reportedly held the view that the U.S. had made a strategic miscalculation by relying on large and increasingly vulnerable aircraft carriers ... In a 1982 congressional hearing, legislators asked him how long American carriers would survive in an actual war. Rickover’s response? “Forty-eight hours,” he said.
True. But these carriers are just large jobs programs which also let us bomb poor countries here and there. And of course they look cool as hell.
If anyone attacks our carriers in large numbers they'll also be the target of our nuclear missiles. So in a way our conventional weapons have to just look cool on paper and be usable against 3rd world countries (that is why A-10 is still in use even though Russian tanks have long stopped being vulnerable to them. But groups of farmers with AK-47s are still blown to bits easily).
If Chinese or Russians launch their ballistic anti-ship missiles at these carriers, soon they'll be seen ballistic missiles flying at their mainland, coming from some place in Nebraska probably.
- mcphage 10y ago> If Chinese or Russians launch their ballistic anti-ship missiles at these carriers, soon they'll be seen ballistic missiles flying at their mainland, coming from some place in Nebraska probably. I mean, sure, but if they're going to be destroyed quickly anyway (as you admit), then why are spending so much money on them?
- rdtsc 10y agoAs I pointed out it is a jobs program, they look cool, and they let us "project power". Meaning we park it by Afghanistan and launch fighters to bomb stuff on the ground. Or go and "indimidate" the Chinese in their disputed naval territories. Not that we don't already have enough bases around the world, but it is nice to have a floating base. Jobs programs is not a joke. If you know anyone from a town with a military contractor facilities or a large base, those bring money into local economy. Congresspeople will go to great legths to ensure military buys more of whatever brings in jobs and cash back where they are from. Here is an example: http://www.military.com/daily-news/2016/02/11/ohio-wins-again-in-armys-budget-for-more-m1-abrams-tanks.html http://www.military.com/daily-news/2016/02/11/ohio-wins-agai... nobody needs more tanks, they are just hadning that over to Lima, Ohio so people there have jobs. Yeah we want to be able to maintain the tanks and all but that is just the official spin and justification. If they can do it for tanks, you be they do it for other, bigger toys.
- mcphage 10y ago> If they can do it for tanks, you be they do it for other, bigger toys. I get that, but why does the jobs program need to be specifically aircraft carriers? Why can't the jobs programs be drones or cruise missiles or stealth submarines or missile ships? Those are all pretty sweet, and won't makes us look as bad if they're quickly sunk in an engagement.
- BWStearns 10y agoWelders unions don't have the skills needed for producing drones. You can employ a shitload of medium skilled workers on building carriers.
- throwawaysocks 10y agoOr roads and bridges and railways and free hospitals?
- metaphor 10y ago> I get that, but why does the jobs program need to be specifically aircraft carriers? Why can't the jobs programs be drones or cruise missiles... Different colors of money, for starters[1]: DoD cannot procure drones or cruise missiles with funds congressionally appropriated for Navy shipbuilding and conversion. Doing so would be a violation of the federal Misappropriation Act[2]. Furthermore, shipbuilding has a 5-year obligation window vs. 3 years for every other procurement activity[3]. > ...or stealth submarines or missile ships? From a defense strategic perspective, levels of consideration are far more complicated than you might imagine[4]. The concept of a defense ACAT <any_level> program explicitly publicized as a "jobs program" is mindblowingly corrupt. I didn't interpret the article referenced by the parent as being about building more tanks without an inherent need for them. I read it as acknowledging that the cost associated with sustaining a niche industrial infrastructure with a steep learning curve to ensure military readiness--as seemingly high as it may be--is still far less than the alternative of closing the doors of "the only tank manufacturer in the U.S." to save for the now at the risk of not being able to ramp up domestic production if the strategic need ever arose in the future--the consequences of the latter being irrepairable. On a related note, it may surprise some to learn that there are literally hundreds of reserve cargo ships loaded with things like HMMWVs and spit-shine-new M1 tanks strategically scattered across the world, sitting idle and ready...and yes, they're regularly serviced. [1] https://dap.dau.mil/acquipedia/Pages/ArticleDetails.aspx?aid=9f96cbe4-ed8f-4d20-94c9-b89130c0eb70 https://dap.dau.mil/acquipedia/Pages/ArticleDetails.aspx?aid... [2] https://dap.dau.mil/acquipedia/Pages/ArticleDetails.aspx?aid=7c811aac-4799-4b38-adf2-88a53699d142 https://dap.dau.mil/acquipedia/Pages/ArticleDetails.aspx?aid... [3] https://dap.dau.mil/acquipedia/Pages/ArticleDetails.aspx?aid=9be81897-aae7-4b76-8887-f9334c6d77af https://dap.dau.mil/acquipedia/Pages/ArticleDetails.aspx?aid... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Capabilities_Integration_Development_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Capabilities_Integration... [5] http://www.marad.dot.gov/ships-and-shipping/strategic-sealift/office-of-ship-operations/ready-reserve-force-rrf/ http://www.marad.dot.gov/ships-and-shipping/strategic-sealif...
- gozur88 10y agoNone of what you've written here makes sense. The Russians don't have ballistic anti-ship missiles. There's only one model in the world so far, and it's Chinese. It's large, expensive, and incredibly complicated, so they don't have many. It relies on a trio of satellites that can be compromised in various ways, and can be destroyed on the ground. It can also be shot down by the SM-3, which is pretty widely deployed by now. I do not believe the US would respond to conventional missiles with nuclear missiles. For one thing, there wouldn't be any need - we could do a whole lot of damage to China with aircraft and cruise missiles, so there wouldn't be any need, and why invite a Chinese nuclear response? That would be suicidal. Russian tanks are still vulnerable to the A-10. If we just want to attack "groups of farmers with AK-47s" there are much more efficient solutions, like Embraer's Super Tucano II, for example.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> It's large, expensive, and incredibly complicated, so they don't have many. From the article: "Navy Capt. Henry Hendrix estimated China could produce 1,227 DF-21D ballistic anti-ship missiles for the cost of a single U.S. carrier." > It relies on a trio of satellites that can be compromised in various ways... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21 indicates China is actively improving and expanding this satellite capacity. > ... and can be destroyed on the ground. You can say that about every weapon system in the world. If China built thousands of these, there's no way you're taking out all of them in a preemptive strike. > It can also be shot down by the SM-3, which is pretty widely deployed by now. Again, China can build thousands. An entire carrier battlegroup is going to have at most a few hundred SM-3s.
- gozur88 10y ago>From the article: "Navy Capt. Henry Hendrix estimated China could produce 1,227 DF-21D ballistic anti-ship missiles for the cost of a single U.S. carrier." Yes, and so what? They have not done it. >https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21 indicates China is actively improving and expanding this satellite capacity. Not as quickly as the US is improving its ability to knock them out. We have literally thousands of missiles that can take out satellites in LEO, and more every day. And that doesn't take into account things like jamming and lasers which could disable a satellite without blowing it up. >You can say that about every weapon system in the world. If China built thousands of these, there's no way you're taking out all of them in a preemptive strike. That's not how it works in real life - you don't have to take them all out. You only have to take out enough that between manufacturing defects, design failures, ECM, control systems degradation, antimissile systems, smoke, chaff, and more exotic stuff like lasers and rail guns, the remaining missiles don't hit a carrier. And remember, these are conventional missiles - they have to actually hit the carrier, which is not an easy thing to do. It's not like lobbing a nuke and calling it a hit if it lands within fifty miles of the target. >Again, China can build thousands. An entire carrier battlegroup is going to have at most a few hundred SM-3s. Again, so what? You're comparing a deployed carrier group today with a Chinese arsenal at some future date following a huge production spree they don't seem particularly interested in undertaking. Saying you can build x missiles for every carrier is a meaningless statistic - it assumes a reasonable response from the US would be to build more carriers instead of upgrading the defenses of the carriers (or, more accurately, the carrier battle groups) we already have.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]