3 ms·
This question was anwered in a prior recent HN thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11849172 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11849172 Not an exper
by kibwen 10y ago
This question was anwered in a prior recent HN thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11849172 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11849172
Not an expert so I can't vouch for its veracity, but I'll inline it:
"This can theoretically be more efficient than growing plants under sunlight. Chlorophyll mostly absorbs light in the 400nm to 700nm band which is about half of all the photons that hit lights. Even in that band ~24% (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthetic_efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthetic_efficiency) of the energy in them in lost due to the higher energy photons (closer to the 400nm side) being converted to lower energy photons.
"So right there plants are only 25% efficient at collecting energy from photons. This is why you see indoor plants grown under red LEDs. Modern commercially available solar panels are about 21% efficient so that is actually getting close to plant can do (I'm not going to include inefficiencies in power conversion right now). Solar panels in the high 40% efficiency range exist, but they are crazy expensive and only used on things like satellites.
"So using current (very advanced) technology we could actually get about double the plant output per area land by using the most advanced solar panels we have to collect light energy to power LEDs."
- Retric 10y agoAssuming zero production costs, 100% efficient LED's, 100% efficient energy transfer, 100% land coverage with Panels that perfectly tile the surface, zero panel degradation, zero dust, etc etc. In the real world wind energy probably works out much better.
- petra 10y agoSure it's great for optimizing land use. Agricultural land is cheap. The real question is cost.
- yetihehe 10y agoYeah, but imagine this on deserts. You havae too much light and almost no agricultural land. So, use panels to gather light, use hydroponics/aeroponics to grow plants and now you can distribute your sunlight to many levels of racks (which can be underground under panels which means even more efficiency than on normal land.
- nl 10y agoNot sure if you are responding to the correct parent? Quote: Sure it's great for optimizing land use. Agricultural land is cheap. The real question is cost. Yes, deserts are even cheaper than agricultural land. But that isn't the problem. The problem is the upfront capital cost of building an underground greenhouse system, the solar panels and getting the water. Yes, once you have all that, you can produce more efficiently than normal production. And in a couple of hundred years[1] you will actually be ahead. [1] No, I haven't done the maths. Maybe it is 10 years, but the point is still the same. It's never going to produce the profits needed to make an investment of that magnitide[^1] [^1] Unless you are growing drugs.
- narrator 10y agoI think Las Vegas would be a great place for vertical farming. Heavy local demand, constrained water usage, cheap power, high ambient temperature. What's not to like?
- grogenaut 10y agoExcept this: http://www.eenews.net/stories/1060002129 http://www.eenews.net/stories/1060002129 wouldn't make long term plans on hoover dam.
- nl 10y agoAgain(!) the investment needed.
- walrus01 10y agoThe cost of building large 5+ floor concrete structures that can take significant floor loading in kilograms per square meter? Building vertical anything isn't cheap, this is why you see massive cloud scale datacenters built into "shell" warehouse buildings that are tilt-up concrete walls, the whole thing 1 story high sitting on a concrete slab. Usually in some places where land is cheap in $/square meter. Example: Datacenters in The Dalles, OR.
- mdorazio 10y agoThis math is incorrect. Look at the wikipedia article percentages - each one is a percentage of the preceding one, not of the total light hitting (if you add up the percentages, they sum to way more than 100%). The 24% figure is 24% of 30% of 47%, or about 3% in actuality. 40% efficient solar panels also do not exist as far as I know (and are impossible) - I think the user is confusing other forms of solar energy collection with photovoltaics. See my other answer below for a better breakdown.