7 ms·
The fact that an article like this has to be written should say enough about these type of cryptocurrencies and the people who "invest" in them. If you don't u
by slg 10y ago
The fact that an article like this has to be written should say enough about these type of cryptocurrencies and the people who "invest" in them. If you don't understand the time value of money, the value of liquidity, or how bubbles work, you probably shouldn't be in charge of your own investments.
- exstudent2 10y agoThat's a pretty condecending opinion to take while Bitcoin reaches its multi year high and Eth and DAO are at all time highs. Maybe it's people who don't understand disruption and technology who shouldn't be in charge of their investments? Not really though since no one should concern themselves with anyone else's investments...
- frank_jaeger 10y agoAll time highs are kind of a sign of a bubble, and say nothing about the liquidity of any investments or the time value of the return you can expect from them.
- exstudent2 10y agoBy all means don't invest then. It's pretty presumptuous to think people who see things differently need to be "educated" though (as the OP is attempting to do).
- TylerE 10y agoI think it's a natural pushback to the over-the-top evangelicalism of the crypto-cultists.
- aianus 10y agoFYI it's fairly easy and cheap to short BTC now if you really believe this.
- bduerst 10y agoWhere? The first hit on a Google search is a Quartz article from three years ago.
- alcio 10y agoBitfinex
- bduerst 10y agoThat's an uninsured, international exchange. At the rate exchanges are "hacked", why would I ever trust them enough to put my money into it?
- codingmyway 10y agoIG Index has bitcoin as an instrument. The spreads are terrible though so I wouldn't recommend it. If it was easier to short DAO tokens I'd think about it.
- codingmyway 10y agoDamn. Should have more than just thought about it.
- alexbeloi 10y agoI imagine the few people sitting quietly with >1k btc understand quite well the problem of liquidity, that it's impossible for them to sell of such large quantities without crashing the market and taking huge losses, their only choice if they want to cash out is to slowly trickle it out without disrupting the market. For everybody else, whose potential trading volume is very small relative to the total btc supply pool, btc is just like any other security.
- placeybordeaux 10y agoLiquidity is a problem, but not at the 1k BTC scale. 24 hour volume was 300k BTC yesterday, so moving 1k BTC over a day shouldn't cause a market crash.
- flatline 10y agoEven moving a small amount of counts can affect the market, because there is no real anonymity: people watch the large wallet balances and large known holders for signs of coins moving to e.g. an exchange.
- biot 10y agoTulip bulbs were once at an all-time high as well, much like the people who bought them.
- anonbanker 10y agolook how downvoted you are! Truth that conflicts with the HN hivemind is regularly greyed. Best to see what the top voted comments in cryptocurrency-related posts say, then do the exact opposite.
- exstudent2 10y agoThat's been a successful strategy for me. I'm still up on DAO even after the drop :)
- drcode 10y agoThe fact that people are even able to write about a decentralized financial entity with emergent behavior in the first place says something, too.
- josu 10y agoYet, if you had invested in bitcoin 5 years ago you would have outperformed Berkshire Hathaway's lifetime performance. In my opinion if you are young, it makes sense to make these kind of bets, and it doesn't necessarily mean that you are misinformed. Cryptocurrencies are certainly onto something, and it's still not clear which one(s) is(are) going to win, so by buying them you are not only making an investment but also voting with your money. I do believe that the DAO will crash and burn, but the truth is that among the people that bought DAO tokens, I don't know anybody that invested a significant amount of their savings. Furthermore most of the people used the Ether they bought at 100th the current price when it first launched. Last but not least, as an economist, the DAO is a fascinating experiment, but I do hope that nobody loses their life savings because of it, which brings me back to your initial comment that raises a good point.
- powera 10y agoIs Bitcoin supposed to be an investment or a currency?
- jonny_eh 10y agoYes
- conception 10y agoExactly. Is the dollar a currency or an investment. It's both.
- colanderman 10y agoThe dollar undergoes inflation. That makes it a pretty terrible investment. (It is, by definition, outperformed by near-zero-risk I-bonds.)
- ptaipale 10y agoThe dollar doesn't necessarily have inflation in comparison to my national currency... and it may be the most readily available investment opportunity that helps you avoid poor national economic policies.
- wslh 10y agoWith your reasoning you should prohibit lotteries.
- bduerst 10y agoNo - by their reasoning, people who can't manage money should not be allowed to play in lotteries. Which they really shouldn't.
- kbenson 10y agoBut then in CA we wouldn't have a way to pay for education... because by the same reasoning the state planners shouldn't be allowed to play the lottery either.
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoOnly because CA stupidly outlawed itself (via Prop 13) from paying for education the normal way (property taxes).
- Bartweiss 10y agoAnyone writing about arbitrage in the tone of "free money found!" can and should be discounted. Arbitrage doesn't create value, so its profit is always taken out of someone else's hide. Always, always, always. If you think you've found it, you need to explain why the people you're fleecing haven't seen the same thing you have, and why they won't act to interrupt you as soon as you start the process. The people seeing an easy profit for the DAO have failed at both of those tasks, apparently failing to understand that they would be engaging in illiquid currency speculation and moreover that they would be doing so publicly, open to price manipulation. Outside of this guy (https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2015-02-27/arbitrage-discovered https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2015-02-27/arbitrage...), people claiming open-ended 'arbitrage' really aren't suited to investment.
- programmarchy 10y agoArbitrage acts as a price finding mechanism, which does have value in the long run. See price convergence.
- anonbanker 10y agothe more FUD (like your post) that comes out about ethereum, the stronger my urge to invest in learning Rust, in order to use Parity[0]. I've been downvoted every time I buck the trend, and I've experienced financial gains almost proportional to my downvotes. I'm still living off the profits I made after the last bitcoin debasement (check my post history to see when). Bought back in at $400/BTC, and _really_ enjoying the profits I'm currently looking at. 0. https://ethcore.io/parity.html https://ethcore.io/parity.html