4 ms·
> basic problems understanding logic and execution flow I don't disagree with this. My point is that layers of obfuscation on top of the really difficult bits
by kibwen 10y ago
> basic problems understanding logic and execution flow
I don't disagree with this. My point is that layers of obfuscation on top of the really difficult bits only make it harder to devote attention to the difficult bits. Beyond a certain threshold, beginners throw up their hands and walk away, especially if they're motivated only by curiosity (which seems to be the target audience of this app).
I know I reached this stage as a teenager when trying to learn C++ (because I wanted to make video games, you see, and everyone told me this was the only language to use), and trying to perform even the simplest operations was piled under layers and layers of seemingly-arbitrary nonsense. I gave up and didn't touch C++ again until after college.
In all, I think there's survivorship bias at work here. We say that these things aren't a problem, that they aren't barriers to understanding, but the only people here in this discussion are the ones who haven't already become discouraged. It's no wonder when things are seen as not-a-problem by people who didn't have a problem with them.
- stormbrew 10y agoI'm not sure appealing to survivorship bias is useful here, since presumably you are also a survivor and just as subject to it. But my argument was based on my observations of other people trying to learn. My experience learning was quite different from most that I've observed, and my observation has actually been that the way I learned is the one that works for fewer people. This is an area of interest for me, so I take opportunities to see how people learn as much as I can. If anything, the better argument against what I'm saying is that it's just anecdata, which is true. I'd welcome research to prove this one way or another, though. Tools like this are quite unlike what I had available to me, and I think they are a much bigger step to creating learning environments for real computing than trying to shoehorn natural language into a box it just doesn't fit. We have been down that road so many times and it never works out the way proponents suggest it should.