2 ms·
I would like to see two-axis voting. Up/down would mean, "valuable/non-valuable". Right/left would mean "agree/disagree" -- the easiest possible way to register
by gojomo 17y ago
I would like to see two-axis voting. Up/down would mean, "valuable/non-valuable". Right/left would mean "agree/disagree" -- the easiest possible way to register opinion without the effort of composing a reply.
Up/down would show a net score, like now. Right/left would show both totals -- perhaps even a little inline sparkline bargraph (perhaps initially hidden).
It's reasonable that people want a lazy, one-click way to show disagreement. It's problematic that impulse gets channeled into the same downvote-gesture-tally that also means "this is spam; this is rude; this should be sunk and faded out of existence". Those meanings are scolding; the effect of a downvote is censorius (by the ranking/fading). It's coarsening for conversation to cross the signals for "I respectfully disagree" and "your comment should be penalized".
- vog 17y agoI don't think that an "agree/disagree"-axis would be very useful. If you disagree, just reply and explain your disagreement. That adds more value to the discussion. I'm not interested at all in the number of agreements or disagreements to my statements. I'm only interested in those who agree/disagree and care to elaborate on their point.
- gojomo 17y agoIf it were as simple as asking people to only disagree with a thoughtful response comment, it would have already been solved. The participants we actually have often can't be bothered to do more than a grunt's worth of disagreement. This gets channeled into downvotes, which carry a slight 'sting' of moral judgment, and spawn big threads like this one every so often. An outlet for one-click-disagreement separate from one-click-censure could help remedy the actual problem without requiring an unlikely change in the behavior of the mostly-anonymous, distracted downvoting hordes.