4 ms·
I've long thought that an even better way would be a strong curve in the capital gains tax structure. Currently, if held ,1yr it counts as ordinary income, >1y
by toss1 10y ago
I've long thought that an even better way would be a strong curve in the capital gains tax structure. Currently, if held ,1yr it counts as ordinary income, >1yr gets cap gains treatment of 28%.
Better would be something like the following holding periods and tax rates (obviously a mere sketch subject to tuning):
<1 minute = 95% cap gains tax rate
<1 hour = 80%
<1 day = 70%
<1 week = 60%
<1 mth = 50%
<1 qtr = 40%
<1 year = 30%
<2 yrs = 20%
<5 yrs = 10%
<10 yrs = 5%
>10yrs = 0
The short end would eliminate the volatility, unfairness and flash-crashes created by submillisecond trading. The encouragement to the longer end would get everyone to think longer-term. The 0% for decade+ holdings would prevent a lot of silliness around inheritance (e.g., you inherit a few shares from your grandfather, and have no records or reasonable way to figure the cost basis, but are required to assert one).
Of course, I doubt it would happen because it isn't in the short-term interest of the bankers.
- a13n 10y agoI like your approach but a 95% tax rate is insane and would cause the market to be incredibly illiquid. Something like 50% to 0% seems a lot more appropriate.
- toss1 10y agoI see why it seems nuts, but then holding a position for less than a minute seems nuts also. That kind of trading is not primarily providing liquidity, its primarily skimming and front-running. IMO, it should probably be banned. However, I think that providing a 95% tax rate is a lighter touch, and allows people to do it if they can find sufficient profit. I also mentioned being open to tuning the amounts. What rate would you think would be good for such short term trading?