3 ms·
> Then why are people arguing? I honestly don't think I wrote anything even slightly contentious in my original comment. I think your original interpretation w
by kbenson 10y ago
> Then why are people arguing? I honestly don't think I wrote anything even slightly contentious in my original comment.
I think your original interpretation was slightly pedantic, and even though, to your credit, you were very careful to repeat your exact phrasing multiple times in many comments, nobody commented on what was likely the crux of the difference (which I have to admit, I'm confuses as to why that was ignored). Should everyprogram be converted? Definitely not. Is conversion even necessarily the goal? I think not. I think the goal is to get a rust representative of each area for promote choice.
It's about trust, and not necessarily how much I trust the specific developer, but that in using a language the requires specific conformance to compile, I can replace some subset of the trust I had to afford to the developer to the tool I use to compile. Do I trust code written by DJB or the OpenBSD developers? Yes. Would I like a way to transfer some amount of that level of trust to the random author of a library on github that would be really useful for my work? Hell yes. Does that replace my need to look for markers, whether in the code or based on project/author status, to determine whether the project and/or developers are competent and trustworthy? No, but it can reduce it.
> I agree, but I believe more benefit will likely be gained by writing new libraries and programs, not from rewriting old ones. I think only concrete absolute necessity should guide any rewriting effort.
Depending on what you mean by "new libraries" (new concepts or new versions?), I don't think that's sufficient. True, most of the real benefit of a rewrite or new implementation of a need won't happen from a language conversion from an existing library, but if it comes down to getting a new (for example) libc and our choice is to convert a small implementation so there's something or to wait for the next project to come along and hope they don't choose C, I'm happy with the conversion for now. If we're lucky, it will also show those about to start on the next libc-like project that Rust is a viable option, so it isn't done in C.