7 ms·
Unfortunately, this sort of linkbait headline has become typical for Scientific American (which is one of the reasons I haven't subscribed for years). As has al
by pdonis 10y ago
Unfortunately, this sort of linkbait headline has become typical for Scientific American (which is one of the reasons I haven't subscribed for years). As has already been pointed out in these comments, the Standard Model is already believed to be incomplete by particle physicists, and discovering a new particle in this general energy regime is exactly what everyone has been hoping for for a couple of decades now. Yes, such a new particle is not included in the Standard Model--because there hasn't been any experimental evidence for one. If this discovery pans out, particle physicists will finally be able to start model building again the way it was done when the SM itself was built: based on good experimental data.
- busyant 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline... "This story is a great demonstration of my maxim that any headline which ends in a question mark can be answered by the word "no." The reason why journalists use that style of headline is that they know the story is probably bullshit, and don’t actually have the sources and facts to back it up, but still want to run it."
- guelo 10y agoYou didn't really say anything the article didn't say.
- pdonis 10y agoI also didn't say some things that the article did say (and which I think are unjustified). For example: "This could mean nothing less than the fall of the Standard Model of particle physics (SM)" No, it means that the SM is an approximation to a deeper theory, which everybody already believes anyway and has for several decades. Models don't "fall" just because they turn out to be approximations. "The SM describes what the building blocks of the universe are and how they work, and from there, at least in principle, explains every other phenomenon in nature." No, it doesn't. The SM doesn't include gravity. It also has twenty-six free parameters that have to be determined from experiments; it doesn't explain why those parameters take the values they do. So it's obviously incomplete, and everybody has known that for several decades. (Yes, the article does go on to talk about the SM being incomplete. But that just means it contradicts itself.) In short: the article talks like this discovery is somehow a huge change in how everybody views the SM. In fact it's business as usual: we built experiments to try to discover new physics to help us extend a model we knew was incomplete, and now those experiments are bearing fruit. This is normal science. It is not some huge rift in particle physics.
- daveguy 10y ago> In short: the article talks like this discovery is somehow a huge change in how everybody views the SM. In fact it's business as usual: we built experiments to try to discover new physics to help us extend a model we knew was incomplete, and now those experiments are bearing fruit. This is normal science. It is not some huge rift in particle physics. and >The SM doesn't include gravity. It also has twenty-six free parameters that have to be determined from experiments; it doesn't explain why those parameters take the values they do. 26 free parameters. Yikes. At what point does the addition of parameters and particles break through from "yet another particle we expected" to "this is completely unexpected and we need to seriously modify our understanding". Obviously with geocentric vs heliocentric it took a major shift in understanding before epicycles crumbled. Same with newton to einstein -- a major shift in understanding before minor errors were explained. Aside from the SA hyperbole, do you think there is any evidence that particle physics is reaching critical mass in terms of convoluted explanations? Of course, it could be the case that nature is just damn complex at the particle level.
- pdonis 10y ago> At what point does the addition of parameters and particles break through from "yet another particle we expected" to "this is completely unexpected and we need to seriously modify our understanding". I don't think a shift like this is precipitated by exceeding some limit on free parameters. It's precipitated by a new discovery not fitting with current models. When the Higgs was discovered, it was just a confirmation of what the SM already predicted; it filled in another free parameter in the SM (the Higgs mass, which had only been roughly estimated before), but it didn't point the way to any new, more fundamental model. This new evidence, if it pans out, does point the way to some new, hopefully more fundamental model, because it's something that isn't included in our current models. That is true even if it has no effect at all on the number of free parameters in our theories. (Btw, the 26 free parameters in the SM sounds like a lot, but since it includes all of the fundamental interactions except gravity, those 26 are really just a collection of all the free parameters from previous theories of those same interactions. For example, the mass and charge of the electron were already free parameters in electrodynamics, so the SM didn't add them on out of nowhere.) Also, as I've commented already, the SM has been understood to be incomplete for several decades. Everybody already expects that there will have to be a significant shift in our understanding when we go to the next level down. We just don't know what that shift will be, because up to now we've had no experimental data on the question. Now we might finally be getting some.
- arcticfox 10y agoI don't understand what's wrong with the article headline. For years, the theorists were ahead of the experimentalists and were just waiting for the Higgs to be confirmed while they simply speculated about what might be next. This, for the first time in a long time, would put experimentalists ahead of theorists. That could easily 'crack wide open' a new set of theories to explain the possible particle. Hardly click-bait here, IMO - the content is sufficiently exciting relative to the headline.
- pdonis 10y ago> I don't understand what's wrong with the article headline. "Crack Wide Open" implies, to me, that this discovery somehow shows that particle physics is on a wrong track and needs to drastically change course. (In other comments I've pointed out statements in the article itself that give the same impression.) That's not the case at all. Particle physics has been stalled because of the lack of new experimental data to help theorists extend their models. This discovery, if it pans out, will help particle physics to start up again, exactly as particle physicists have wanted to do for quite some time.
- jessriedel 10y ago"Crack Wide Open" does not imply that at all. It implies a difficult problem that suddenly yields. When the police officer on the murder drama says this clue will "crack the case wide open", he doesn't mean they've been doing their police work wrong.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pdonis 10y ago> "Crack Wide Open" does not imply that at all. In isolation, it might not. Taken by itself the phrase is open to multiple interpretations. But in the context of the article as a whole, I think it does.
- gfodor 10y agoYour reply seems to indicate that this is a yawn, but while the article is a bit hyperbolic, it seems to me that experimental evidence of a new, hitherto unforseen particle is about as disruptive of an event one can expect in particle physics, no?
- pdonis 10y ago> Your reply seems to indicate that this is a yawn No, just that it's not the kind of event the article is trying to portray it as. > it seems to me that experimental evidence of a new, hitherto unforseen particle is about as disruptive of an event one can expect in particle physics, no? No, it's not disruptive. What has been disruptive has been the several decades without any new experimental results that could help particle physicists to extend their models. Now we might finally be back to the way science is supposed to be done: building theoretical models using experimental data as a guide. This is what particle physicists have been hoping for; it's not a disruption at all.
- gfodor 10y agoUh, isn't a situation where something that has been going on for several decades suddenly changes the very definition of 'disruptive'? :)
- pdonis 10y ago> isn't a situation where something that has been going on for several decades suddenly changes the very definition of 'disruptive'? Not if the sudden change is exactly the one that everyone in the field has been working for and hoping for.
- anotheryou 10y agoIt's the kind of headline that makes me skim the comments first :)
- feider 10y ago"New particle is not included in the Standard Model--because there hasn't been any experimental evidence for one.." What?! That statement is absurd - reminds me the story of how geocentric model was "adjusted" when new measurements came along. That just leads to overfitting a model. The property of a sound theory is that it can predict future data; it does not just rationalize on data already acquired.
- pdonis 10y ago> That just leads to overfitting a model. My phrasing evidently did not make my point clear. The SM has been known to be an approximation (the usual term is "effective field theory") for several decades; and furthermore, there are well-understood reasons why that particular model is a good approximation up to a certain point. None of that changes if and when we discover experimental evidence of new particles not included in the SM (as we might now have done); in particular, the structure of the SM itself will not change. What changes is that now we have (hopefully) some evidence to help us build the theory at the next level down, the theory to which the SM is an approximation. That process will not consist of adding parameters to the existing SM (which would be "overfitting"). It will consist of building a new model and then showing how the current SM arises as an approximation in the new model. If we had had this evidence several decades ago, what we now call the "Standard Model" would be that new model instead of the one we currently call the "Standard Model"; we could have jumped to the next level then instead of having to wait.
- dang 10y agoWe replaced the baity title with the less baity subtitle.
- pdonis 10y agoNote: the headline here on HN is no longer linkbait as the moderators have toned it down. But the Scientific American one still is.
- Aelinsaar 10y agoIf you want a good read on this topic that isn't pop-sci crap, (and also not months late) I suggest: https://profmattstrassler.com/2016/03/18/the-diphoton-excess-improves-a-bit/ https://profmattstrassler.com/2016/03/18/the-diphoton-excess...