5 ms·
I thought another problem was that there is no market for shorter flights if they are still too long to do in a single day? To give an example - Concorde's 3h
by gambiting 10y ago
I thought another problem was that there is no market for shorter flights if they are still too long to do in a single day?
To give an example - Concorde's 3h flight time from London to New York was perfect, because there were people actually interested in going to US/UK for a day for business and coming back the same night. But Concorde wasn't very popular on longer routes, because if you were going to spend 6 hours on a plane you might as well spend 12 and fly overnight, getting some good sleep, and saving yourself a tonne of money.
- pm90 10y agoIt depends on the customer. Many executives would rather spend the extra money to save time.
- gambiting 10y agoSure, but it reminds me of the issues French railways were facing recently after introducing new super-fast trains. Turns out, there's a lot more people interested in trains that take 12 hours to get somewhere but which arrive at reasonable time(say, leave at 8pm, arrive at 8am) than trains that are much quicker, but arrive at 3am at night, which is a stupid time - it's too early to stay up, too late to go to a hotel. Overnight flights are similar .
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoAgreed, and this is why it makes sense to allow the Concorde to (noisily) zoom over the Atlantic while not necessarily subjecting flyover state Americans to sonic booms from New York to LA. As for the longer flights, the 16 hour Los Angeles->Sydney experience is hellish. Depending on the price, I would certainly shell out to get there quicker.
- terravion 10y agoI can think of a ton more people who want to go from SF to NY (LA to DC, etc) or vice versa for the day than I can people who want to go to London for the day. Flying supersonic, you could actually get some work done on the other end. My guess, is that supersonic flight would be a huge boon to California, making it much more practical to locate 2,000 miles away from the geographic concentration of customers.
- ghaff 10y agoLots of people go between New York and London for quick trips. BA even has business class-only flights between City of London airport and NYC.
- ghaff 10y agoIn business or first, I wouldn't describe trans-Pacific flights as "hellish." More like long and boring. But you almost certainly get into range issues with supersonic on those routes. A longer non-stop flight in a premium class is probably going to be preferable to a flight that has to stop in, say, Anchorage to refuel.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoI wouldn't be complaining if I didn't fly coach.
- ghaff 10y agoYes, but I think it's fair to say that any supersonic service would cost more than business/first in subsonic planes today. Therefore, it doesn't make a lot of sense to look at supersonic passenger flight as a fix for traveling trans-Pacific in coach.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoSo you'd be willing to pay more for a faster flight but you aren't willing to pay more for a better class of seats?
- njloof 10y agoYes. I can live with a cramped seat for 4 hours, plus I get an extra day at home on each end in place of travel time. And I don't end up at a hotel at 10AM waiting for my room to be ready.
- ghaff 10y ago>plus I get an extra day at home on each end in place of travel time. That seems optimistic. East coast US to western Europe (which is the 3-4 hr scenario you mention for supersonic flight) you're cutting a get-in-late flight (or a redeye) to an SST leaving in the morning to arrive in the evening. Which isn't gaining a day. Returning, you can already get a direct flight from Europe that leaves in the AM and arrives early PM. An SST still isn't gaining you a day. Theoretical long haul routes over the Pacific potentially gain you more but now you're potentially sitting in seats for 8+ hours and it's pretty much a guarantee that no carrier is going to offer that sort of flight with cramped seats.