3 ms·
Leaving aside the question of whether most patents actually document something innovative, if you really think that patents can protect innovation, see the rece
by JoshTriplett 17y ago
Leaving aside the question of whether most patents actually document something innovative, if you really think that patents can protect innovation, see the recent post by Jonathan Schwartz: http://jonathanischwartz.wordpress.com/2010/03/09/good-artists-copy-great-artists-steal/ http://jonathanischwartz.wordpress.com/2010/03/09/good-artis... .
Also, I'd like to suggest one reason to distinguish software patents from others: they hurt more, and they kill certain types of development. If a mechanical engineer has to license a patent and pay a certain amount per widget, that might cut into their profit margin or raise the cost per widget, but it won't necessarily kill the product (unless the patent owner outright refuses to license). If a software engineer has to license a patent for a FOSS project, even a fraction of a cent per copy would kill the project, because it fundamentally can't work with a FOSS license.
Note that I've worked with mechanical engineers who give away their designs under similar terms, at which point they'd face exactly the same issues; however, this represents a far rarer case than in software.
That said, I do personally agree that patents in general ought to go away. However, I think that software patents do a lot more damage than some other kinds, and therefore it makes sense to focus on them first; they also represent a newer and more tenuous concept that we can more easily fight.
- protomyth 17y agoFor most physical things, I like patents. As an example, without patents, no sane company would produce drugs. I don't even really have a problem with "Design" patents (pretty narrow, easy to avoid). It's the concept of this ethereal stuff that bugs me. The IsNot patent and the One Click show the system is broken. Heck, look at the xor patent. I think the easiest way to have wrote the law is that it must be a physical object to be patented. Otherwise protect it with copyright.