9 ms·
The comments here are hilarious, they really reveal the IT bubble. The only real complaint about this purchase would be that LinkedIn was overvalued. And I wou
by oblio 10y ago
The comments here are hilarious, they really reveal the IT bubble.
The only real complaint about this purchase would be that LinkedIn was overvalued. And I wouldn't bet on that since Microsoft surely sent a big team of their brightest cookies to make a valuation of the company.
But other than that, LinkedIn fits: it is a corporate social network, if you will. I know that "corporate social network" is almost an oxymoron, but bear with me. It is social in the sense that users register and interact with each other just as on a regular social network, but ultimately the service is corporate focused. LinkedIn has created one of the biggest and best maintained databases of employment information (and of possible business contacts) in the world. As TheArcane said, LinkedIn is "Facebook + Monster on steroids".
If you don't believe me, try to speak to people you know, active professionals outside of the IT sector and see how many of them have LinkedIn profiles. Better yet, talk to people who are not in employer-dominated sectors (i.e. not like IT, where the demand for qualified workers greatly exceeds the supply).
- argonaut 10y agoExactly. I had LinkedIn on my list of undervalued tech stocks, and I think this bears that out. LinkedIn has absolutely no competition. LinkedIn is the world's biggest, virtually-complete graph of most enterprise organizational charts / structures. That alone will be valuable for Microsoft's enterprise business.
- _yosefk 10y agoMS could, erm, look up those org charts on linkedin.com for $0 (indeed very useful at times.) What value is added by buying LinkedIn for $26G? How owning LinkedIn is going to add $1-1.5B/year (assuming eventually you want a P/E between, I dunno, 15 and 25), to MS's revenue? (I'm sure someone at MS has an answer to this, it's just that they haven't been tremendously successful in the past with their big acquisitions; I don't think Skype or Nokia paid off. And in general tech companies often buy other companies without much apparent success. Why is it so crazy to doubt their wisdom in any particular instance?)
- tajen 10y ago> MS could look up those org charts That's the best remark in the whole thread. Employee poking at competitors. Sales teams looking up the right people to connect with. Thanks to the LinkedIn share button, like Facebook, they can have parts of your browsing history. I don't even know whether the purchase should be allowed.
- boundring 10y agoWow. In terms of data mining this is still a huge price-point, but obviously some team at MS projected the benefits vs expense.
- shostack 10y agoYeah, once integrated, I'd be worried if I was an MS employee using it to scout competitors and talk to recruiters. This also gives MS some great data to possibly feed into the team that manages their investment portfolio. How valuable would it be to have a (admittedly not perfect) feed of employee growth/deflation for various companies? That would also provide a ton of leverage for future acquisitions, etc. There's a LOT you can learn from LinkedIn data if you have access to the unfiltered data.
- tajen 10y agoExactly! And the gold weapon would be able to see all employees' corporate and private emails, along with their search queries. Uh oh.
- garyclarke27 10y agoReminds me of the joke - MS Executive buys Skype for $8bn - didn't anyone tell him you can download it for free?
- novaRom 10y ago> What value is added by buying LinkedIn for $26G? 1. Integrate Skype into LinkedIn 2. Add a shared chat screen (video group chat) This will allow many Human Resources to perform interviews more efficiently (in return to subscription). I can imagine many other new attractive features MS could easily add (e.g. syntax highlighting in group chat).
- btown 10y agoIt's actually a brilliant synergy. LinkedIn was limited to a revenue model around HR, recruiters, and individuals buying subscriptions to different views of their core service. They weren't in the business of building CRMs, enterprise email solutions, or operating systems. And yet those very systems are the ones where people most natively would want to ask "what is the context and history of the person I'm connecting to?" Beyond the expansion in potential revenue models, it's rational for Microsoft to spend their cash on things that cement their dominance in the workplace, particularly as Apple and Google could always choose to make a hard push into that space. Assuming LinkedIn continues to dominate as a professional network, Windows 15 Powered By LinkedIn is a hell of a moat to cross.
- blahi 10y ago>And I wouldn't bet on that since Microsoft surely sent a big team of their brightest cookies to make a valuation of the company. Yeah, I'm sure they did the same with Yammer too.
- barrkel 10y agoLinkedIn is very big in enterprise sales, for example - gathering intel on the org.
- blowski 10y ago> And I wouldn't bet on that since Microsoft surely sent a big team of their brightest cookies to make a valuation of the company. The same people who valued Nokia ($7.6 billion writedown) and aQuantive ($6 billion writedown)?
- matsur 10y agoDifferent people. Both of those acquisitions were in the Ballmer era.
- dpkrjb 10y agoDon't Microsoft own a fund? Wouldn't they realistically send the same team to value Linkdin and Nokia?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- blackflame7000 10y agoWould you send the same people after the job they did last time?
- inopinatus 10y agoThis criticism is only valid if you can show that the due diligence team that worked Nokia also a) misreported the red flags / the enterprise value of the acquisition, and b) were responsible for mismanaging the post-merger integration. A good deal of M&A goes ahead despite the warnings from the DD team. Sometimes it's a matter of CEO ego, sometimes a strategic long shot overruling the red flags.
- alex_c 10y agoIt's easy (and fun!) to criticize in hindsight, but there was a strong strategic case to be made for the Nokia acquisition back then. Obviously it didn't work out, but given Microsoft's cash reserves at the time it wasn't even a particularly large gamble.
- mooreds 10y ago> it is a corporate social network I'd go further and say it is a global corporate social network (unlike, say Yammer, which is a local corporate social network). I agree that this is a fantastic play by MS. When I am researching both job candidates and employers, LinkedIn is one of the two resources I use (Google being the other).
- yef 10y ago"Corporate social network" is nowhere near an oxymoron. The value of strong and weak connections alike is critical to businesses and professionals.
- anentropic 10y agodoes anyone actually interact on LinkedIn? I thought it was just a platform for recruitment spam
- Kiro 10y agoRecruitment spam or not it works and mediates a lot of jobs and connections. I don't think you should diminish LinkedIn's role on the job market. And yes, a lot of my colleagues are very frequent users of LinkedIn for sharing and discussing business related stuff. With that said these tend to be non-techy people. Techy people tend to use sites like HN instead.
- icebraining 10y agoIn my experience, there's plenty of sales people and middle managers posting stuff and commenting. Usually platitudes and mangled quotes from rich people, plus submissions of their company's marketing blogs.
- stcredzero 10y agoThose things are just the neurotransmitters spewed by people who are becoming analogues to neurons. (Not aware of why they are filtering and passing on signals, but somehow performing some kind of decision making in aggregate.)
- jpindar 10y agoAbsolutely. Various technical forums are active despite the horrible, horrible UX.
- webtechgal 10y agoCouldn't have been said better - I mean, even a small, less than half-way competent team could easily build something providing a (much) better UX as compared to the LinkedIn forums.
- hkon 10y agoI get most of my gigs through contacts on linked-in.
- HelloNurse 10y agoAs far as it is a "corporate social network" the interests of all LinkedIn users, both the good and the bad ones, do not benefit from forcing integration of Microsoft software, accounts, paid services etc. down their throat.
- maxxxxx 10y agoI am not sure what their goals are with this but they are definitely showing that they don't want to be in the technology business anymore.
- boundring 10y agoNnnnnnnnnn-maybe. Seems more like a partial swing towards enterprise-emphasis.
- VOYD 10y agoConsidering the Yammer failure, This purchase makes no sense whatsoever. Satya is flushing MS down the toilet.
- vtlynch 10y agoHere is the main problem: Who likes LinkedIn? Sure, we can debate its usefulness, how popular it is outside of IT, etc. But I think across the board, no one LIKES LinkedIn.
- malka 10y agoYou dont need to be liked to be popular. How many people like facebook ?
- vtlynch 10y agoThats my point though. You dont have to be liked to be popular, but it becomes a lot easier for someone else to become popular if you are not liked. And I do think the general sentiment towards Facebook is much more positive than LinkedIn.
- c_c_c 10y agoFacebook is irritating and intrusive. LinkedIn is spam. It's garbage used because legacy and lack of alternative.
- tedmiston 10y agoIt seems like recruiters do. Obviously most engineers don't.
- genzoman 10y agoi like it ok. it directly led to my current job, and couple other good offers. for $0 i can't complain.
- GCA10 10y agoWell said. There are lots of reasons for skilled software engineers to despise LinkedIn. They don't need its version of networking, and they find recruiters' endless serenades tiresome. But in most other lines of work, the recruiters don't knock so often (or so cluelessly) ... and the access to other people's profiles actually is quite handy. Sales. Finance. Media. Education. Law. Non-profits. It's a long list. It's anyone's guess whether Microsoft can execute the bulk of its strategic plan for LinkedIn. But the plan is not foolish.
- sanderjd 10y ago> They don't need its version of networking I don't really get this - it's weird to me that when I meet other developers at meetups or conferences or wherever, it doesn't seem "cool" to connect on LinkedIn, but nothing else fills that same role. I'm happy to trade GitHub profiles, but unless both of us do most of our interesting work in the open, which statistically we don't, then that's a much less informative profile.
- rpgmaker 10y ago> And I wouldn't bet on that since Microsoft surely sent a big team of their brightest cookies to make a valuation of the company. By that simplistic reasoning no big company would ever make a mistake.
- e1452654a78d238 10y agoValuations are a funny thing. There's sooo much cash floating around in large companies coffers doing nothing (especially Microsoft's) that the numbers start meaning a whole lot of nothing after awhile.
- new_guy123 10y ago> The only real complaint about this purchase would be that LinkedIn was overvalued. And I wouldn't bet on that since Microsoft surely sent a big team of their brightest cookies to make a valuation of the company. That kind of justification has almost always gone wrong. Its a great acquisition. But is the price justified?