3 ms·
Any action? Lets look at some specifics and ask which ones should count as murder. A reasonable person might see a different degree of justification in each cas
by belorn 10y ago
Any action? Lets look at some specifics and ask which ones should count as murder. A reasonable person might see a different degree of justification in each case.
A person wielding a gun is running and firring their weapon towards a solider. The solider shoots back and kills them.
A boat full with military weapons enters an areas which marines are defending and refuse to turn back. The marines sinks the boat.
A tank drives into a town. The Solider defending the civilians attacks the tank and the tank driver dies in an explosion.
A bomb plane that drops bombs on military facility with tanks, airfield with bombers on them, and docks with military ships.
A bomb plane that dropping bombs on a factory that produce tanks and guns, killing workers.
A bomb plane that fire bombs on housing districts to demoralize the population.
A person is driving down the road in uninhabited area, and a solider sends a remote missile.
A person is celebrating a wedding in their own house, and a soldier sends a remote missile to kill everyone in the wedding.
- tajen 10y agoI don't see what degree of difference there is in your first 4 examples: They're all armed people in a situation of war. Of course the last 3 are murders (although we know that the Allied erased most of German and Japanese cities, including the civilian neighbourhoods, for morale and retaliation) and the 4th before the end (killing military workers) is debatable. Last point, concerning French nationals who went to Syria twice to train in military camps and came back to lead the terrorist attacks with actual killings: Can we please extend the Geneva convention to consider them ennemy military corps (and thus, prisonners of war)? I have zero tolerance for police investigating innocents or listening to everyone, but once we know what they've done, I wonder why they just face some penal law (a few years in jail, max, like a driver in a car accident).
- tajen 10y agoI don't mind the downvotes, please explain first how parent's 8 examples are different, and how people being trained in enemy military camps and coming back doesn't raise the POW legislation.
- golergka 10y agoI'm sorry — what point, exactly, are you trying to prove right now, and how do you think this point contradicts my original comment?
- 7Z7 10y agoWhose soldiers? Whose civilians?