7 ms·
Scripts enabled required article, not bothering to read. Similarly, Hollywood in general has shown me every other time that I've given 'film adaptation of X' i
by mjevans 10y ago
Scripts enabled required article, not bothering to read.
Similarly, Hollywood in general has shown me every other time that I've given 'film adaptation of X' in my life that the original form was better. Were I interested in the story of WoW I suppose the best form to experience it in would be in the actual game (I've heard players of that game admit that parts of it are better left un-played and that they are this fine with the now more rapid ascent to newer content in the game).
- mikeash 10y agoIt's a common refrain that films based on other stuff are always worse, but I think it's sampling bias. When a movie is based on a mediocre source, people often just don't realize that the movie isn't original. The fact that a movie is "based on" is more likely to be known if the source is good, and reversion to the mean means that these are likely to have movies that aren't as good. For one example, Forrest Gump is based on a pretty crappy book. It's mildly entertaining but it's pretty wacky and definitely not the amazing classic that the movie was. For another one that turns up a lot, The Godfather is said to be a lot better than the book, although I haven't read it myself. One more, Pirates of the Caribbean, while not exactly deep and meaningful, is a pretty fun movie based on a pretty mediocre amusement park ride. I will admit that I can't come up with any good movies based on a video game. Another source of trouble, I think, is that a movie based on something well known can survive on name recognition, so it doesn't have to be good. A Warcraft movie could be good in theory, but they probably haven't bothered.
- HannibalLecter 10y agoThe two that stand out as best video game adaptations were Silent Hill and Resident Evil. Sure some of the aspects of each were utterly annoying fanboy service, but for what they were -- video game adaptations -- they were done right. Warcraft isn't a video game adaptation though. The lore within the mmo is its own story, and so the film could have easily adapted the story over the idea of a video game, which is probably why the film fails on so many levels. WoW lore is rich. Powerful. And it has lost its way since about The Burning Crusade expansion. I don't see Blizzard ever getting it right again. Have you seen the latest expansion footage? Everyone is Illidan. Everyone can have warglavies. Basically all the greatest things the game ever introduced that were hard to get are handed out to everyone so nothing matters in the game anymore. It's garbage. The movie is garbage, unsurprisingly.
- xahrepap 10y agoPrince of Persia Sands of Time. I liked that movie quite a bit. :) Only video game based movie I've seen and liked. Granted, it's only related by name from what I understand.
- douche 10y agoGo read the Godfather - it's an excellent book. Mario Puzo does some good work. Another really interesting one is his book on the Borgias[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Family_(Puzo_novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Family_(Puzo_novel)
- csense 10y agoWoW takes place way later than the movie. The story shown in the movie is during the events of the original Warcraft: Orcs and Humans real time strategy game (from 1994).