3 ms·
My opinion/experience: Karma and other systems may have their social uses, but the single most effective means to improve a social setting is to set a better e
by Mz 17y ago
My opinion/experience:
Karma and other systems may have their social uses, but the single most effective means to improve a social setting is to set a better example. Resist the temptation to snipe at people. Give the benefit of the doubt and first assume misunderstanding rather than malice and, if possible, attempt to clarify rather than attack or defend. Don't take things too personally. If I am in a personal space (not feeling well, recently had something negative happen to me, etc) where I am feeling particularly prickly and thin-skinned, just walk away and come back another time when I am less likely to make a mole-hill into a mountain. And so on.
My experience over the years is that if I engage in more socially effective behavior and do so consistently, eventually, other people will begin to mimic some of those behaviors. Not because they think highly of me, but just because it works. If people don't know a better way, they fiddle around and do whatever it is they do know and then vent about their frustrations. Show them a better way and many people will eventually happily and voluntarily adopt those methodologies because it makes their own lives better. If you want to live in a better social "ecosystem", look to "the man in the mirror" (though, technically, in my case it is "the woman in the mirror") and work on their behavior. Then have a little patience. Sow the seeds. It will bear fruit (as long as you don't then pull it up by the roots to check if it's growing :-D ).
- wynand 17y agoI think that really hits the nail on the head. I don't know if people will ever stumble upon a set of interaction constraints that will make people civil if they're not already committed to civility. In that regard HN has always been good (but not perfect, as evidenced by some of the episodes mentioned in this comment section). If someone lashes out and gets a calm response instead of being downvoted to oblivion or without being baited, the whole atmosphere becomes much less toxic (even if the original commenter insists on trolling).
- Mz 17y agoIf someone lashes out and gets a calm response instead of being downvoted to oblivion or without being baited, the whole atmosphere becomes much less toxic (even if the original commenter insists on trolling). The other thing a calm (compassionate, tolerant) response does is it tends to prevent "train wrecks". One of the biggest problems with many online forums is the tendency for everyone to try to jump into the fray to "defend" righteousness and goodness and what not, thus keeping the fighting alive. Many of them are attempting to put a stop to the fighting but they miss the fact that fighting against the fighting is still fighting. Many people seem to just not know how to effectively defuse a negative situation and put a stop to it, which is a very different skill set than "arguing"/fighting. Fighting against it is the typical knee-jerk response of the vast majority of people, even for most very well educated and intelligent people. "Train wrecks" are best diverted by redirecting the flow of conversation in a constructive fashion rather than attacking the person who has said something that sounds asinine (but maybe wasn't really intended to be, they could be having a bad day or it's a pet peeve they aren't wholly rational about, etc).
- yters 17y agoThat works as long as your example is visible. However, with voting the problem is that bad examples are much more visible than good ones.