3 ms·
Thanks very much for the links, I haven't seen most of them. In my opinion, upvotes should be used to promote any comment that provides a unique or underconsid
by cookiecaper 17y ago
Thanks very much for the links, I haven't seen most of them.
In my opinion, upvotes should be used to promote any comment that provides a unique or underconsidered point-of-view on the topic at hand, to indicate enthusiastic agreement, or to encourage users. For instance, if someone posts a comment that says what I would have said if they had not said it, I upvote it, because I enthusiastically agree and that user has saved me the time I would have spent typing it out, and usually introduced an element I hadn't considered. Or, if a user has posted a thoughtful comment with a divergent take from the rest of the group, even if I don't agree or don't care, I will often upvote that because it will get people thinking and hopefully generate good discussion. I will also upvote comments that have caused me to reconsider an opinion, or that make a point I hadn't yet considered. Those comments expand my mind and experience, and are good.
I find myself upvoting a lot of things I otherwise wouldn't upvote recently, primarily because I don't think the comment is worthy of downvotes it has received. For instance, http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1188846 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1188846 is the comment that pushed me over on posting this, and it had a score of zero when I found it. I didn't find it particularly useful or insightful, and I didn't really have much opinion on its content, but I didn't think it deserved a downvote, and I upvoted it to get it back up to 1.
I try to reserve my downvotes for lines of thought or discussion that are either useless or actively damaging to the community. I don't think a comment deserves to be buried and its user penalized by karma removal merely because I disagree or don't find their comment interesting. I think of the vote buttons as a tool for communal cropping, I suppose, not a personal comment rating system.