3 ms·
>I've got a theory that string theory is more of a sociological phenomena than real science. Yes. I have a friend with a PhD in physics, and he says that a gen
by TheOtherHobbes 10y ago
>I've got a theory that string theory is more of a sociological phenomena than real science.
Yes. I have a friend with a PhD in physics, and he says that a generation of string theory people basically just shouted everyone else down in a rather obnoxious way. Other critics (e.g. Lee Smolin) have said similar things, albeit slightly more politely.
At some point it stopped being science and became more about careers, reputations, funding, and paper mills. Which, given the way that academia works at the moment, became self-sustaining.
Some interesting math has fallen out of string theory, but it should never have been allowed to hold back other approaches to quantum gravity to the extent that it has.
Considering the amount of time and paper involved, there's a huge wall of maybe-perhaps-if but very little solid physics to show for the effort.
Incidentally, that blog is a real find - some of the clearest explanations of hard concepts I've seen anywhere.
- tim333 10y agoIt reminds me a little of the phenomena of efficient market theory in economics / finance. Academics were drawn to it partly because it enables them to do a lot of fancy mathematics whereas if you look at inefficiencies like the stuff that went on in the movie The Big Short then the academics don't really have much of an edge against people working in the field. So much academic stuff goes 'assuming efficient markets', blah blah... which is not actually wrong but maybe a misallocation of resources from looking at bubbles and crashes which could have helped avoid the whole 2006 episode. I agree the blog seems very good.
- eru 10y agoIt gets more complicated, because there are various `strengths' of efficient market hypotheses around. The weaker ones are obviously true, but the stronger ones are more suspect.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoAbstruse Goose also has some deep wisdom about string theory. I particularly like this one: http://abstrusegoose.com/424 http://abstrusegoose.com/424
- eggy 10y agoYes, I am glad about this blog too. Lee Smolin's 2006 book 'The Trouble with Physics' first alerted me to this, since I am not a string theorist, and I like to read about the applied physics going on instead. I would like to read the theoretical math, but my mind can only deal with beginning grad-level math at most. Nonetheless, I like to burn some wood and try at times. I just don't want to waste it on what is seeming to be more and more of a rabbit hole.