2 ms·
>most of the questions you've asked are really quantum field theory questions: the string theory connection is almost entirely unimportant in that regime My is
by tim333 10y ago
>most of the questions you've asked are really quantum field theory questions: the string theory connection is almost entirely unimportant in that regime
My issue with the two electrons repelling scenario is that in normal quantum field theory it's modeled, I think, as the exchange of virtual photons and given that we don't really understand what a photon is and that they have odd spread out kind of properties that seem to allow that sort of interaction between distant things I can accept that that happens even if we don't understand how it fully. When you get to "emit and absorb virtual photons by pinching off into new tiny strings" and similar ideas though I just can't see it. My hunch is electrons and photons are in their base nature more abstractly mathematical and attempts to model them as bits of stuff will fail.
- Steuard 10y agoI'll be honest: high energy physics isn't really an area where "hunches" carry a lot of weight, at least if those hunches aren't grounded in a pretty thorough understanding of particle physics and general relativity. The language of "pinching off into new strings" is of course largely an analogy, one which captures some of the mathematical features of string interactions reasonably well while probably obscuring others. What's really going on underneath that analogy is just as "abstractly mathematical" as you could ask for: a (boundary?) conformal field theory defined on the 1+1-dimensional string world sheet, which allows just a single unique self-consistent mode of interaction. It is complicated, but honestly, so is standard quantum field theory when you really dig into it, and if you're familiar with the underlying math and physics this description is surprisingly elegant.