3 ms·
It's a fundamental mistake to assume that these are "real" strings being talked about. String theory is about the idea that reality is best modeled as, notiona
by XorNot 10y ago
It's a fundamental mistake to assume that these are "real" strings being talked about.
String theory is about the idea that reality is best modeled as, notionally, strings - i.e. the mathematics looks a bit like them if you sort of squint and look at it really hard.
But there's a really good reason strings are a compelling here: because near as we can tell, vibrational frequency is really important to particle physics - the energy of a photon is quantized as E=nhf , (Energy = integer * planck's constant * frequency). And this seems to scale all the way down - it works for photons, it works for electron orbitals, and it comes into play dealing with the virtual particles which are exchanged in force interactions.
So however you describe reality, whatever you do, your abstraction pretty assuredly needs to somehow recover the vibrational importance, which implies certain kinds of "geometry". You get "strings" because strings are one of the most fundamental structures which can hold a vibrational mode, and importantly, they kind of neatly explain the quantization as standing waves - closed strings can only setup a standing wave at certain frequencies depending on their length, same with open strings (the wave needs to be zero at the ends of the "string" or it'll lose energy).
Of course this is all my very ad hoc handwavey explanation of it, but the point is, there's a lot of very basic physics which works quite well in the model. It did not, and does not, just come from nowhere even at this very high level.
- tim333 10y ago>really good reason strings are a compelling here: because near as we can tell, vibrational frequency is really important to particle physics I can give a sort of counter argument. Fair enough the relationship between frequency and energy and also wavelength and momentum are fundamental to physics. But consider maybe the classic experiment where you demonstrate that, where you have a barrier with two slits and fire particles at it and get an interference pattern on a screen on the other side. You can calculate how close the interference stripes will be using λ = h/p and this works not only for point particles like electrons but more complicated ones like helium atoms or C60 molecules. How do you explain that with strings? There's definitely something going on like the amplitude state of the universe changes according to the difference in momentum for different particle paths but I see no way you can explain it using strings.
- Trombone12 10y ago> It's a fundamental mistake to assume that these are "real" strings being talked about.
- macspoofing 10y ago>I can give a sort of counter argument. You can't because you clearly have an incredibly shallow understanding of string theory (I do too). For one thing, you're completely stuck on the metaphor of the 'string' and you're trying to apply it to a very shallow understanding of Quantum Mechanics and complaining that it doesn't make sense. Okay. I think it's cool to talk about fundamental research but taking it one step further and saying that some theory X isn't correct because it doesn't make sense to ME, a non-professional physicist, is a step too far. Be more humble.
- tim333 10y agoYup I don't understand it. I'm not convinced others really do either though.
- auntienomen 10y agoThere's a minimum threshold of understanding required to make intelligent commentary on topics like this. Muddled pop-sci and half remembered undergrad material doesn't cut it.
- tim333 10y agoFair enough but is my description of two slit interference patterns wrong and is there any way you can explain the result with string theory?
- auntienomen 10y agoYou can explain it with any quantum mechanical theory. Talking about strings here is a red herring. That's why people are calling you out.