8 ms·
I've seen many of these ring-road simulations over the years. They are great for pitching lower speed limits, but I fault their assumptions. Traffic does not
by sandworm101 10y ago
I've seen many of these ring-road simulations over the years. They are great for pitching lower speed limits, but I fault their assumptions. Traffic does not feed on itself in this manner. Aberrant drivers and situations are constantly being inserted and removed from the system. A slowdown at point A does flow up/down to point B like a wave, but it doesn't wrap around back to point A to be amplified again.
I do credit this particular simulation for modeling acceleration/deceleration. Playing around with it leads to the conclusion that many congestion problems can be addressed by increasing the performance numbers for cars, and by encouraging people to use their brakes/engines to their full potential. We should all drive as if in nascar,
minimizing gaps to fully utilize the available road. Clarkson would be proud.
I would like to see a simulation of cars+trucks+motorcyles. Two-wheeled vehicles are common everywhere and in some countries are dominant on the roads, yet they are never included in these models. And toss in a few bicycles just for kicks.
Realworld "simulation":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7wm-pZp_mi0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7wm-pZp_mi0
- platz 10y agoagree, I don't find ring-road simulations convincing.
- seanp2k2 10y agoAnd yet, many believe that the best way to reduce traffic jams is to accelerate as slowly as possible, brake as softly as possible, and leave as large of a gap in front of them as other drivers will allow. Normal drivers, unaware of the above, will generally also stop and go slowly in traffic jams. My personal pet peeve is when there is a reason for a slowdown (emergency vehicle, crash, etc) and drivers slow down further to look at it, unaware that they're are then currently causing the jam they just waited in.