3 ms·
As soon as you get v1.0 life, it starts bioforming its environment. v2.0 life would have to evolve in the changed environment - which would be considerably les
by TheOtherHobbes 10y ago
As soon as you get v1.0 life, it starts bioforming its environment.
v2.0 life would have to evolve in the changed environment - which would be considerably less hospitable, because the most useful chemical processes and energy sources will be colonised by v1.0 life.
v1.0 life will (more or less literally) get the low hanging fruit. v2.0 would have to evolve around the edges, which means the probability gradient is higher and therefore less likely.
- ThePhysicist 10y agoBut I think this actually happens with normal life as well: Individual species of bacteria try to conquer a biological niche by shifting conditions such that only they can survive. But by doing this they invariably create chemical by-products that can be harnessed by other life forms, thereby fueling their growth. It's an interesting question whether there are any biospheres on Earth that are colonized exclusively by a single species of life (I doubt it). So although it's a very valid point I'm not sure if it's a sufficient argument against the hypothesis of having two independently evolved and fundamentally different types of life on a given planet.