4 ms·
> And just today, Google was accused of whitewashing Hillary Clinton's record and not showing negative autocomplete terms. That was a pretty silly accusation.
by tzs 10y ago
> And just today, Google was accused of whitewashing Hillary Clinton's record and not showing negative autocomplete terms.
That was a pretty silly accusation. It was mostly based on comparing Google autocomplete terms to Bing and Yahoo autocomplete terms. To show a pro-Clinton bias on the part of Google what you need to concentrate on is comparing Google autocomplete terms for Clinton searches to Google autocomplete terms for other people.
Do that experiment and you find that the kind of things that appear to be removed from Clinton autocomplete are also removed from the autocomplete of many other people, including many politicians, current and past celebrities, and criminals.
There is a good discussion of how Google tries to avoid autocompletes that could be seen as disparaging here [1].
[1] http://www.clayburn.wtf/2016/06/google-probably-isnt-manipulating-search-results-to-favor-hillary-clinton.html http://www.clayburn.wtf/2016/06/google-probably-isnt-manipul...
- jillop 10y agoDirect quote from Google: "...Our Autocomplete algorithm will not show a predicted query that is offensive or disparaging when displayed in conjunction with a person’s name..." So, I guess somebody at Google is deciding what is offensive or disparaging? And we shoulld trust that the standard is being applied equally to both parties, in spite of Google having a vested interest in the Democrats? OK, let's see. There is a VERY VERY popular nickname for Secretary Clinton, "Crooked Hillary", which has been widely reported on, and is all over Twitter. So let's try: "Crooked Hil" -> The final item in the list is "Crooked Hillary Bernie". Which makes no sense. Why not remove it entirely? Now let's try Trump. "Crooked Tru" -> First item on the list is "Crooked Trump". Which isn't even a meme or anything. Politics is full of offensive and disparaging statements. By censoring those terms, Google is presenting a worse search product to the world.