3 ms·
"Reasons that this particular author hates cars" is a bit more like it. Of course, if you pick the worst of everything of suburbia, you can "prove" that it suc
by rconti 10y ago
"Reasons that this particular author hates cars" is a bit more like it.
Of course, if you pick the worst of everything of suburbia, you can "prove" that it sucks. But the author utterly fails on a large number of points, such as proving that humans like to feel enclosed by buildings on both sides such as on Saint-Germain, and that they utterly hate being able to actually see the sky like in the "middle of nowhere". And hey, he hates GarageHouses because they worship at the altar of the car. How terrible. Tsk, tsk. Of course he hates that ugly house's façade, but he's unable to prove that tacky design is a necessary consequence of suburbs.
I live in a suburb. The houses are not all the same. I love cars and motorcycles; we've got 4 motorized vehicles at the moment. None of them fit in the garage because we don't have some absurd cookie cutter house. We don't have an absurd cookie cutter house, because that doesn't fit our aesthetic.
We live in a relatively quiet neighborhood that is, yes, zoned residential, but we're also a block from restaurants and a bar and a grocery store. We don't have winding meandering streets that get you lost; we're literally 2 blocks from the freeway.
Oh, and I can and do bike a few miles to work despite the fact that public transit sucks.
I love visiting cities, but could never live in one. Guess what? I don't want shared walls. I don't want to have to worry about where I'm going to park my cars or whether the windows will be intact when I return, or whether I'll be kept awake by the sounds of mixed-use blissful commerce happening beneath me.
He's right about so many things but just falls victim to boring old tropes. I also lived almost-spitting-distance to a grocery store in an apartment once. Thanks to a 10ft high brick wall, I had to walk 5 minutes out of the complex, 5 minutes around, and 5 minutes back in the direction of the store; 15 minutes to go what was really a few hundred feet as the crow flies. Of course it's absurd, so I didn't keep living there. But this does not make suburbs hell. It makes poor design choices hell.
- amyjess 10y agoI agree with you on all points. > "Reasons that this particular author hates cars" is a bit more like it. Yep. Reading the article, every time I read one of his numbered points, I just thought "But that's a good thing". They only make sense as negatives if you already have an irrational hate for cars. > And hey, he hates GarageHouses because they worship at the altar of the car. How terrible. Tsk, tsk. On a related note, I found the author's rant about alleys utterly nonsensical. I live in the suburbs of Dallas, where alleys are everywhere. Most suburban neighborhoods here have large networks of alleys where trash cans are located and garages empty out.