5 ms·
It might be unpopular here, and I feel slightly guilty saying it, but I like suburbia. Mine has wide streets, plenty of tall trees, it is quiet. I like flowers
by rdtsc 10y ago
It might be unpopular here, and I feel slightly guilty saying it, but I like suburbia.
Mine has wide streets, plenty of tall trees, it is quiet. I like flowers in my yard, etc. I like my neighbors, but they are not within literally an arms length on each side of me every day.
Unlike probably most people here who grew up in suburbs, then perhaps started to hate it and moved to one of the coasts, to a city, I grew up in a city in an apartment. Proximity to stores, public transport and being able to walk is nice. But crime, full public transport during rush hour, noisy neighbors, or simply being flooded by neighbors from the top, crowding, dirty streets, etc. Even grocery shopping was annoying, yeah could walk to the store, but couldn't bring home a car trunk's worth and not worry about for another week.
So rationally, on a general scale, I can understand why suburbia sucks. But as an individual, I don't plan on moving to a city, the trade-offs are not adding up for me.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoSuburbia has many fine traits, but it also has a bunch of problems, first among them that it's generally financially unsustainable (not enough taxes raises to support large, sprawly infrastructure when it eventually needs to be replaced). Other issues include the way suburban residents frequently demand that urban centers design their transportation more around the needs of suburban commuters than people who live in the city itself, and how suburbs frequently use zoning restrictions to keep out lower income people.
- rdtsc 10y agoOh I agree in general that it is unsustainable, and it has all these problems. But will I sell my home and move to a city? Probably not.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoPersonally I'd love to split the difference and live in a European-style suburb. Something not in the main city, medium-density, lots of open areas nearby, good walking/biking, good transit connection to the city. Something like this, basically, except in the US: https://www.google.com/maps/place/Olching,+Germany/@48.2092716,11.3262383,5878m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m5!3m4!1s0x479e7edcd650216f:0x41e48add78b9780!8m2!3d48.20707!4d11.3334755 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Olching,+Germany/@48.20927... Unfortunately, due to a variety of bad transportation and land use policies, this kind of town doesn't really exist in the US.
- op00to 10y agoOh, but it does exist. Inner ring suburbs in most major northeastern cities fit the bill. I live in a detached house with a nice backyard, built in ~1910. I can walk to my kid's school, the grocery store, bars, gourmet restaurants, shopping, arts, and a metro stop that runs 24/7 for a 15 minute trip into the center of a major city. I can get to the center faster than people living in the city itself. I work at home, so I rarely drive. When I worked in aforementioned city, I would commute by metro to my office. I probably drive less than 150 miles a month, mostly on long business trips. Places like this exist, but they are hard to find and often more expensive for a smaller house. It's the perfect mix of urban and suburban for me.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoGood point, they're not completely non-existent in the US, just rare.
- dsr_ 10y agoThis describes basically every town inside 128 around Boston, and the towns just outside 128 are mostly just a little more spread out. If you pick a town with a commuter rail stop, you can get more than 30 miles out of Boston and still have a reasonable public-transit commute to a job in the city proper.
- flubert 10y ago>It might be unpopular here, and I feel slightly guilty saying it, but I like suburbia. Sounds like it is time for an HN poll. How much property do you own? * I prefer to make payments to my landlord (you insensitive clod!). * Greater than 1000 sq. ft. * more than 10,000 sq. ft. * more than an acre (43,560 s.f.) * more than 5 acres * more than 80 acres * more than a section (640 acres) * I only do metric and forgot how to Google
- zippergz 10y agoI agree. I have lived in cities and in the suburbs, and I greatly prefer the suburbs. I also feel that many of the points in the article make unwarranted assumptions about priorities, or are based on opinion. European cities feel “cozy” and “charming” is because they provide a feeling of enclosure, which humans want because it gives them with a coherent sense of place, like rooms in a house. You may want the feeling of enclosure, but I don't. Again, I've lived in both. I don't feel more "cozy" or comfortable in an urban setting. This is just one of several examples. My biggest frustration about articles on this topic is how much they assume we all want the same thing, or agree on what is good and bad. Fact-based arguments like environmental impacts are great. But treating "ugly," "soul crushing" and "isolating" as absolutes isn't very productive.
- WildUtah 10y ago"My biggest frustration about articles on this topic is how much they assume we all want the same thing" It could be clearer but the opening paragraphs talk about how nearly everything in America is suburban. There is no choice for people that want to live in a city. That's because it's illegal to build anything except suburbia. We'd all like a choice. Developers could build suburbia for you and a city for me. But that's not legal and that is what causes the problem. A few older areas exist from before New Deal development laws mandated suburbia in the 1930s. And places like San Francisco and New York are insanely expensive because about half of us want to live there and they haven't been allowed to build any more of it for seventy years while the population tripled.
- abalashov 10y agoAuthor here - you nailed it. There's no useful discussing to be had about personal preferences when practically the entire country, notwithstanding a very small handful of places, is built as described in the artifice. And as prevailing zoning laws, building rules and perverse government incentives currently stand, it is either outright illegal or massively uneconomical (thanks to the distortions) to build anything but Los Angeles. When we have the option for urban living, then we can talk about who wants to live where. As it stands, the usual highway schlock is all the vast majority of us get.
- willidiots 10y agoAs a person with a polar opposite background - grew up on 7 acres in the middle of nowhere - I completely agree. I enjoy living close to employment and services without being completely immersed in humanity 24/7. This whole piece is an exercise in bias. I'm disappointed with Quartz.
- mdesq 10y agoI agree. I live in a small suburban development abutting several larger ones. There are miles of safe walking/jogging sidewalks and roadsides, I can enter the local mountain biking trails that go for miles just at the end of my street, and I can walk down to the small local lake to go fishing with my kid. Plus, the community is especially friendly and there are always neighbors outside chatting, having impromptu get-togethers, or planning the next community coffee or book club. A walk down to the mailbox on a Friday afternoon is as likely as not to have a neighbor hand you a beer or glass of wine while you have a chat and watch the kids practice riding their bikes where there's plenty of room for them to learn. There are downsides to be sure, like anything else, but I didn't grow up in the suburbs and I enjoy it.