3 ms·
So with the bailouts, they took the haircut right away and baked the risk into the deal they made with the auto manufacturers. Then they ate the risk in their
by busterarm 10y ago
So with the bailouts, they took the haircut right away and baked the risk into the deal they made with the auto manufacturers. Then they ate the risk in their transaction right away and wrote down the loss.
With the loans they made to Ford they used a different tactic -- they said to hell with the financial risk (which you usually bake into your interest rate) and made the loans anyway and left open the possibility of devastating financial losses. The only reason we're looking at this positively is because Ford was a success story. Had Ford folded, congressional heads would have rolled and we'd be cursing the TALF loans and praising the TARP bailouts.
- brohoolio 10y agoJust to clarify that the whole banking system was locked up and there was no capital. In a normal market GM and Chrysler could have done what Ford did. Ford was in better shape than the others because they had mortgaged everything before the financial system locked up. That means they also started improving everything sooner. From my perspective in Michigan the auto bailout was a huge success. My friends in the industry report that most of the cruft in the big three was cut or let go and they really shifted the culture. The whole industry is focused on technology. The suppliers survived. Hundreds of thousands of jobs exist because of the injection of liquidity.
- busterarm 10y agoI similarly think that the bailout was a success. I just think that people have a horribly myopic perspective when they act like Ford didn't receive government/taxpayer benefits during the financial crisis.
- jfoutz 10y agoFisker and VPG were clearly failures, Tesla and Nissan seemed to work out ok though. You're clearly much more well versed in this situation than i am. It looks to me like a subsidize what you want and tax what you don't style economic policy, just like corn in Iowa. or FHA loans. But i think we agree (since you changed your terms) it's not exactly a "bailout", but the timing sure was super handy for ford.
- busterarm 10y agoOh man...Fisker. Not that they were doing well anyway, but Hurricane Sandy sure did kill off that company.