4 ms·
The author does a decent job describing the suburbian plight, but doesn't delve into the reasons why deep enough. An older article ascribes suburbian developmen
by prostoalex 10y ago
The author does a decent job describing the suburbian plight, but doesn't delve into the reasons why deep enough. An older article ascribes suburbian development to peculiarities of US economic policy:
http://www.theamericanconservative.com/urbs/the-conservative-case-against-the-suburbs/ http://www.theamericanconservative.com/urbs/the-conservative...
"The sad reality is that, despite the marketing, the suburbs were never about creating household wealth; they were about creating growth on the cheap. They were born under a Keynesian regime that counted growth from government spending as equivalent to that coming from private investment. Aggressive horizontal expansion of our cities allowed us to consistently hit federal GDP and unemployment targets with little sophistication and few difficult choices.
That we were pawning off the enormous long-term liabilities for serving and maintaining all of these widely dispersed systems onto local taxpayers–after plying municipalities with all the subsidies, pork spending, and ribbon cuttings needed to make it happen–didn’t seem to enter our collective consciousness. When all those miles of frontage roads, sewer and water pipes, and sidewalks fall into disrepair–as they inevitably will in every suburb–very little of it will be fixed. The wealth necessary to do so just isn’t there."
- dukoid 10y agoInteresting to see "conservatives" whining about urban sprawl and blaming it on Keynesian policies now -- while they had originally promoted it for nuclear survivability, improving the "feasibility" of a nuclear war.
- amyjess 10y agoAmerican Conservative is a paleoconservative magazine. Paleocons aren't the same as mainstream conservatives; for example, they rail against globalization, they advocate an isolationist foreign policy, they're much more likely to be openly racist and antisemitic (American Conservative is, to its credit, the sole remaining paleocon magazine that refuses to endorse antisemitism), and they take religious conservatism to a farther extreme than most Republicans are willing to go. Paleocons haven't been relevant in mainstream American politics for a very long time. After Robert Taft lost the Republican nomination in 1952, they took a backseat to mainstream conservatives, and since then they've mostly been relegated to third parties and fringe candidacies (like Pat Buchanan's 1996 and 2000 campaigns, and the Constitution Party). This may be changing, though, as Donald Trump's economic and foreign policy stances are straight-up paleocon, and his racism isn't a problem with paleocons because most paleocons are overtly racist (again, except the people who run American Conservative). The only reason Trump isn't 100% paleocon is that he's not nearly enough of a religious conservative; your average paleocon is at least as conservative as Rick Santorum on religious issues, while Trump has made few overtures to the religious right, and those few have all been empty platitudes. In short: I wouldn't take an article in American Conservative as being representative of mainstream conservatism at all.
- gnaritas 10y agoWhenever you see conservatives complaining about anything related to the Keynesian regime, you can bet you're reading a bunch of horse-shit with little if any basis in fact. Government policies didn't create suburbs, people trying to get out of cities did, not everyone likes city life and it's cheaper to live further out than it is in the city. Suburbs are the natural result of a car culture and plentiful land to build on. No Keynesian conspiracies required.
- tpolm 10y ago>Government policies didn't create suburbs It is exactly the opposite. American suburbs were created by goverment policies (specifically, by certain tax breaks for development industry and by tax breaks for home owners, not to mention housing subsidies)
- bitwize 10y ago...To give whites a place to go to git away from them coloreds. Racism, or more broadly classism -- the refusal to come together in community and the tendency to draw bright lines between self and other, and order society so as to only have to deal with people like self while avoiding other -- is at the very heart of American social structure, at all levels.
- WildUtah 10y agoMinimum parking mandates are the law most forceful in mandating suburbs. National finance regulations contribute. Concentration on freeway funding is part of it. Setback requirements and floor area ratios require suburbia also. Single use zoning adds up, too.
- rjbwork 10y agoGotta disagree. The easiest example to look at is the Interstate Highway System. They busted up downtowns and put giant highways through them so people could get to and from the suburbs and the cities. Baltimore, Atlanta, LA, DC, Boston, DFW, NO, etc. all have peculiarly similar interstate structures.
- sien 10y agoEverywhere in the rich New World suburbia came up. In Australia, Canada and New Zealand you also have suburbs. US economic policy didn't have much effect there. Suburbia is partly driven by people having cars and having wealth. It works fairly well as long as the city isn't too large and traffic and the problems of having efficient public transit and low densities come up. Another thing that drove suburbs is that cities were not as good as they are now. There were lots of slums and problem areas and people didn't have much space. Living downtown appeals to young wealthy people now but it was less fun living with your parents and possibly your grand parents.