3 ms·
> Making the claim that C is twice as fast as Rust because of 5/10 benchmarks in the "benchmark game" shows an incredible lack of common sense to me. Actually,
by bjourne 10y ago
> Making the claim that C is twice as fast as Rust because of 5/10 benchmarks in the "benchmark game" shows an incredible lack of common sense to me.
Actually, 2x is likely the lower bound of how much faster well-written C is over Rust. Rust developers have an interest in promoting their language so they will make sure their test programs runs as fast as possible. C doesn't need that kind of marketing.
For example, the Rust solutions were all updated in 2015 while the C solutions hasn't been touched since 2013.
> In 5/10 benchmarks, the benchmark games claims Go has equal if not better performance than Rust. Am I supposed to believe now, that a managed, garbage collected, 6-year-old compiler, language is as fast as as language without a runtime running on LLVM?
It doesn't run on LLVM. It takes advantage of LLVM to compile ELF executables. I said that common sense should be used.
- igouy 10y ago>> For example, the Rust solutions were all updated in 2015 while the C solutions hasn't been touched since 2013. Not true: Jun 02, 2016 revcomp.gcc-6.gcc Apr 13, 2016 fasta.gcc-7.gcc Sep 26, 2015 revcomp.gcc-5.gcc Oct 01, 2014 fannkuchredux.gcc-5.gcc Apr 27, 2014 fastaredux.gcc-5.gcc Apr 08, 2014 mandelbrot.gcc-9.gcc Jan 19, 2014 mandelbrot.gcc-7.gcc (There may have been others that have subsequently been removed.)
- Manishearth 10y agoWell, yeah, Rust hit stable in 2015. Its a new language, that's when those benchmarks were first written or fixed to work with the stable compiler. Trust me, most of the C solutions there are very hand-optimized. Less than the rust ones in some cases. While Rust may need that marketing, C folks have had years of time to play the benchmarks game. And there are many more C programmers than Rust programmers. I think enough effort is going into those C programs. Like I said, in practice Rust code sometimes is faster than (otherwise it is as fast as) C code because it is easy to write the fast version using zero cost abstractions. (the benchmarks game is a different realm of optimization, in day to day usage you do not spend that much effort eking out every last cycle; you write code that doesn't have major perf issues and use it)