7 ms·
You can't talk about issue 3 without mentioning things like the EFF, ACLU, NAACP, or any number of legitimate third parties that have made it part of their miss
by slg 10y ago
You can't talk about issue 3 without mentioning things like the EFF, ACLU, NAACP, or any number of legitimate third parties that have made it part of their mission to support cases they think are important. How do you deal with those separately or how would you prevent Thiel from simply creating a similar organization and using it for his own personal agenda?
- tptacek 10y agoMost of the cases ACLU is involved in are against the government, not private entities.
- matt-attack 10y agoNot sure how that's relevant for this discussion.
- scott_s 10y agoBecause most of the ACLU's activities do not fall under this discussion.
- biztos 10y agoIf we disallow cases because the defendant is not the government, doesn't that invite someone to disallow cases because the defendant is the government? (Which of course happens all the time, but still...)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- MichaelBurge 10y agoNo, the government is held to a higher standard because they control the police and military. There are countless issues where I'd say the government should be restricted in a way that private parties are not. Besides, the government already has sovereign immunity to lawsuits unless it chooses to allow itself to be sued. So if anything your first sentence is backward.
- manigandham 10y agobut most != all which clears the way for this
- hinkley 10y agoI was going to say the same thing, but I think this is the key phrase: | litigation where the funder has otherwise has no connection with the merits of the dispute. I think those organizations and other social policy groups can demonstrate that they have a vested interest in the merits of the dispute. In fact that litmus test may be overbroad, allowing any corporation for whom the case is useful to their business strategy to claim they have a vested interest in the case...
- RickHull 10y agoExcept Thiel arguably has "connection with the merits of the dispute". He feels that Gawker violated his privacy as well as Hogan's, and he wants Gawker to be punished and/or discouraged from further similar behavior. Just like the EFF or ACLU.
- huac 10y agothen he should file his own lawsuit. he has no standing to sue over the hogan case
- yummyfajitas 10y agoThe ACLU has no standing to sue over teaching evolution in schools. The NAACP has no standing to sue over school segregation. In all these cases, powerful people with interest in a case decided to assist people who did have standing. Do you oppose that practice in all these cases?
- whyenot 10y agoThe ACLU and NAACP are non-profits that are supported by a large number of members, publicly report their spending, and are governed by leaders chosen through a democratic process. When they back a lawsuit, they are very transparent about it. What Peter Thiel did was secretly fund a lawsuit by someone else in order to exact revenge (or depending on your point of view, to provide a service to society). I think there is a pretty big difference between the two groups.