5 ms·
And that is a major reason military and lots of enterprise customers run on RHEL. It is this seemingly uncool and boring stuff like having STIGs, FIPS-140-2 cer
by rdtsc 10y ago
And that is a major reason military and lots of enterprise customers run on RHEL. It is this seemingly uncool and boring stuff like having STIGs, FIPS-140-2 certifications, EAL-4 etc.
And it spreads like a virus in a way. Say you use Alpine / Gentoo / Ubuntu. You get your first enterprise or DOD customer. They want an onprem version of your service. Now you have to either not sell it o them (but it so happens those customers also come with loads of cash willing to drop it in your lap). Or support both RHEL and Ubunu. So after a while you start to wonder, why bother supporting both, so you switch to CentOS/ RHEL stack only.
I've seen it happen, people grumbled and were angry, but they still would rather have loads of cash dropped in their laps than stick to their preferred OS.
A couple of years back. Remember Mark Shuttleworth inquiring about what would it take for Ubuntu to get some uptake with US govt customers. Remember emailing him a list of some of those requirements and yeah, it is very expensive and time consuming to get those red tape stamps on your product. I don't know if anything happened with Ubuntu in that regard since.
(You can also get exceptions depending on who you sell to, but it only happens if you have friends in high places which can grant those. Say sell to special ops teams, for example).
- chrisper 10y agoMy only problem with CentOS is that it is "outdated." A few times this was annoying because I had hit a bug that was fixed in newer versions. I understand that outdated is a feature of CentOS, but it comes with a trade off. I switched my servers to Ubuntu for now.
- meddlepal 10y agoYou could always run Fedora Cloud: https://getfedora.org/en/cloud/ https://getfedora.org/en/cloud/ But you're back in the world of not having all those certifications which enterprise customers may want. On the other hand it shares common package infrastructure with RHEL so that's a bonus. We used Fedora Cloud for a bit and I liked it. Be prepared for cutting-edge though, for example, journalctld rather than syslog. We switch to Ubuntu for reasons not related to Fedora in particular but just ease of running an Apt repository on S3 vs Yum/Dnf.
- ProAm 10y agoCutting edge is terrible for running a business on though.
- rdtsc 10y agoThere is https://access.redhat.com/documentation/en-US/Red_Hat_Software_Collections/2/html/2.2_Release_Notes/index.html https://access.redhat.com/documentation/en-US/Red_Hat_Softwa... but we didn't use it. Not sure how successful others are with it. But yeah it was a major pain. Remember all the time wasted getting things to work or compile on outdated kernels or standard library...
- IE6 10y agoI think, at least for RHEL, that is a feature.
- digi_owl 10y agoAnd Debian stable, see JWZs ranting on that regarding xscreensaver...
- merb 10y agoThats not true compared to ubuntu. while centos 7 included java8, ubuntu 14.04 did not, both released on 2014. And on CentOS 6 I'm not sure but I think EPEL (which is way more official than any ubutnu PPA) has openjdk 8 for centos 6. there is some software that is maybe "old" but not "outdated" on centos, however as far as I know most software runs on centos, really good. The only thing which has bad support on CentOS at the moment is openssl 1.0.2 and newer nginx/haproxy.
- rdtsc 10y agoIn general EPEL should never override packages from the base system. Other repos do that but EPEL's mission is to provide extra package not newer packages. Otherwise it creates a mess. Someone adds EPEL, updates, now their software which was based of a base package is broken because EPEL upgraded libc or something like that.
- chrisper 10y agoHow is it not true? CentOS is still at version 7 with a 3.x kernel, while Ubuntu is now at version 16.04 with a 4.x kernel. Many os-level packages are not going to get updated until a new major version of RHEL comes out.
- 6581 10y agoWhy are you mentioning 7 and 16.04? Those numbers mean nothing when you compare different distributions.
- marcoperaza 10y agoThose are the current versions of each. The comparison is between the kernel versions, not the distro version numbers.
- 6581 10y ago"still at version 7" strongly implies a comparison of the distro version numbers.
- FatAmerican 10y agoShuttleworth inquired with you personally?
- rdtsc 10y agoIt was an open request to the community from his blog post. I emailed him first, that's how conversation started. http://www.markshuttleworth.com/?s=government http://www.markshuttleworth.com/?s=government
- jimktrains2 10y agoHow does FreeBSD stack up?
- rdtsc 10y agoIn the same category as Ubuntu. There are some things you can do and market your product as an "embedded" device, if it truly is so, but that is a bit tricky. And of course, can get exceptions, that's tricky too, and doesn't scale.
- digi_owl 10y agoNever mind that the chairman of the RH board is a retired general...
- nickpsecurity 10y agoIt's how you get contracts. You pay them then they really pay you. Watchdog groups call it The Revolving Door.
- JustUhThought 10y agoOr lobbying. Or graft/bribery. I suppose it depends on whether you are in the private sector, the public sector, or law enforcement.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoPro tip: do everyone available for best results. ;)
- jamiesonbecker 10y agoThis is a good point. At Userify, we support RHEL7+ (also CentOS), Ubuntu 14.04LTS, and Debian Jessie for the on-site server product (we support a broader range of managed nodes). It's a good point that about 2/3's of our customers use either RHEL7 or CentOS, but we do have customers running on Ubuntu (for instance) in both HIPAA and PCI environments. (We also provide cloud-based SSH key management at no charge with upgrades available, but mostly our customers there are startups, although we do have a couple of public companies on our cloud SaaS platform. Since our revenue is largely driven by enterprises and mid-sized companies that want to run their own in-house and/or in their own clouds, we'll try to accommodate any OS they prefer: normally, that's RHEL, but increasingly Ubuntu, Amazon Linux, and CentOS.)
- simonebrunozzi 10y agoThanks - this is very informative, and from my previous experience at VMW I can confirm this is absolutely right. p.s. Is there a way to know who you are? Cannot recongnize your username and I would be interested in knowing who you are and if we can get in touch.