6 ms·
> Libel and slander have no place in a functioning democracy One man's libel/slander is another man's investigate journalism ("muckraking" in the US). In this
by smt88 10y ago
> Libel and slander have no place in a functioning democracy
One man's libel/slander is another man's investigate journalism ("muckraking" in the US). In this particular case, Gawker wasn't guilty of either libel or slander because they didn't publish anything about Hogan that was false.
> it shouldn't take a billionaire to sue and win judgement against slanderous publishers
It's actually much harder to win a libel/slander suit as a public figure. See: http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/libel-defamation http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/libel-defamation
- pmichaud 10y agoI don't think that poster is talking about Hogan.
- taejo 10y agoYour comment exposed me to the big gap between the meanings of muckraker in US and UK English: 1. (US) One who investigates and exposes issues of corruption that often violate widely held values; e.g. one who exposes political corruption or the poor conditions in prisons. 2. (Britain) A sensationalist, scandal-mongering journalist, one who is not driven by any social principles.
- smt88 10y agoInteresting! I'm going to change my language from "muckraking" to "investigative journalism". Thanks for pointing this out.
- idlewords 10y agoThe term was coined as a perjorative (by Teddy Roosevelt) and then co-opted as a term of honor by the journalists he was attacking.
- davidmr 10y agoAt least in my schooling, Upton Sinclair was held up as the very model of a muckraker, and he was certainly anything but (2) above. Perhaps sensationalist on occasion, but strongly principled.
- idlewords 10y agoRoosevelt was applying the term to journalists at publications like McClure's. There's a great book about this period by Doris Kearns Goodwin (The Bully Pulpit) that I can't recommend highly enough.
- hoorayimhelping 10y agoI'm American and I've only heard a muckraker described as number 2.
- smt88 10y agoProPublica, one of my favorite investigative news sources, describes some of their articles as "muckreads". They use the word proudly, with the implication that they've gone to lengths that the general public would/could not to find out important information. As someone said, it was a pejorative term that was reclaimed, and that makes a lot of sense to me now.
- johnpowell 10y agoTalking Points Memo does the same. http://talkingpointsmemo.com/muckraker http://talkingpointsmemo.com/muckraker
- omonra 10y agoIt was part of the American History 11th grade course I took in HS in the early 90s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muckraker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muckraker
- cjahsh 10y agoAh yes, society should recognize the positive impacts of investigative journalism. I can hardly see a between the Pentagon Papers and a sex tape!
- smt88 10y agoWhat if a conservative politician lobbies for adultery being illegal, and then a sex tape emerges of him cheating on his wife? That's important journalism. What if the CEO of a company intimidates an employee into having sex with him and secretly films it, and that gets released? That's also important journalism. There are lots of other ways sex tapes could be newsworthy: a famous person makes racist comments in it (the Hogan tape!), a Hollywood director asks for sex in exchange for a role, etc. etc.
- anarazel 10y agoBut that's not gawkers business, so ... ?
- cjahsh 10y agoAre all sex tapes journalism? Including revenge porn?
- slg 10y agoThere is a difference between reporting on the existence of a sex tape and publishing said tape. None of the examples you gave require the tape to be published.
- throw10010110 10y agoNone of their examples are even valid. In Hogan's case, this was a consensual act. The fetish is called wifesharing, and the wife testified that it was consensual among all parties. The number of people who are calling this cheating, immoral, etc is sort of terrifying. This is equivalent to a gay couple being caught a century ago, and everyone arguing that it's in the public's interest to know. It's not. It's consensual and harms no one. The sole argument that could be leveled against this is that the husband secretly recorded the act. This isn't good, but "Husband secretly records consensual act" is none of our business. By the way, if someone would vouch my comment (the same way you'd flag a comment, but click "vouch" instead of "flag"), I'd appreciate it. Thanks!
- slg 10y agoDoes that really change the underlying belief? Whether what Gawker did was libel, an invasion of privacy, or any other crime it boils down to Gawker violating the rights of other individuals and building a business model around that practice. This wasn't some brave investigative journalist exposing corruption, this was a hack posting the sex tape of a celebrity. They aren't even in the same ballpark.
- smt88 10y ago> This wasn't some brave investigative journalist exposing corruption, this was a hack posting the sex tape of a celebrity. I agree, but the reason Gawker lost is important. It was because they violated someone's privacy. I strongly support violating the privacy of powerful, public figures in the future if it serves public interest. I agree that Gawker was stupid, greedy, and overreaching here, but I still worry that next time, the sex tape (or whatever it is) will be equally private but much more important to the public.
- slg 10y ago> but I still worry that next time... People are acting like their is no thought put into these type of court cases. This isn't a universal precedent that applies to every situation. It doesn't prevent any journalist from pursuing legitimate news stories and invading privacy along the way. It only prevents journalist from invading someone's privacy where the only story is the invasion itself.
- untog 10y agoHuh? That's not true at all. A billionaire could fund cases against a media company entirely irrespective of the merit of those cases - the media company would still be forced to pay the legal fees associated with defending themselves, even if it's as simple as just getting it thrown out of court. Do it enough times and you've bankrupted the company. For an example, Mother Jones was brought to the brink of bankruptcy for reporting an entirely true and legitimate story: http://m.motherjones.com/media/2015/10/mother-jones-vandersloot-melaleuca-lawsuit http://m.motherjones.com/media/2015/10/mother-jones-vandersl...
- sheepleherd 10y ago| Gawker wasn't guilty of either libel or slander because they didn't publish anything about Hogan that was false. ...not to mention, Hogan's public persona and living he has earned has been by posing as a larger than life clownish character; I don't even see that he was harmed. Ask yourself, do you think less of Hogan now? (and not because it turns out that he has less impressive sounding real name) I'd have more sympathy for a "normal" person.
- saint_fiasco 10y agoHogan can't eat our positive thoughts. He lost a lot of respect among the kind of people that (economically) matter a lot to him, like sponsors and employers.
- blastrat 10y agoI get the idea of what you said, but did he, really measurably? plus: the information released about him was accurate; who says you get to have secrets that disqualify you from jobs that you hide from your employer? I'm not saying we want to have a big brother society, but I am saying if you present yourself as wholesome (whatever that means) and you are not wholesome, then you are false advertising anyway, to people who care about that. Anyway maybe it made him relevant again ("there is no such thing as bad PR"), I had forgotten he existed. Need to wait for some time to go by before it's clear. I'm not advocating a side or devil's advocating, i just prefer the "less outraged middle" over the "outraged extremes"
- kofejnik 10y agoJennifer Lawrence's persona and living are based on being extremely attractive, so was it Ok to hack her iCloud and publish her nude selfies? Strangely, Gawker crowd was very upset that no one went to jail for it.
- blastrat 10y agoI'm not saying Gawker is OK or not, nor that they are hypcocrites or not. I'm talking about the standards that courts use to measure "harm". Young starlets have so many sex tapes (their own and hacked) out there, and it doesn't seem to harm them much. It's almost as if a porn star could make a better claim that they lost the commercial potential of something stolen! Again, I'm not saying that I want to live in a world where it's ok to steal people's sex tapes and put them out there; but I am also noting that in today's world, it is much less of a "harm" or even an embarrassment to people than it was when the system of torts was established. Since torts are based on harm, we run into the issue of "how much harm did this cause?" maybe it needs to be made illegal like "upskirts". (and I'm not advocating that, either. I'm saying, I'd like some clarity to exactly what people are outraged by)