6 ms·
Are you suggesting the Hogan suit was groundless?
by cm2187 10y ago
Are you suggesting the Hogan suit was groundless?
- pcurve 10y agoIt wasn't, but the damage amount is excessive.
- icebraining 10y agoIt's interesting that it was actually higher than what the plaintiffs requested. It wasn't clear to me who sets that, the judge or the jury?
- jdmichal 10y agoJudges almost always set reward. I wouldn't be surprised if it was a heavy slap aimed at not obeying the court order to take down the video. http://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-procedure/sentencing-law-faq.html http://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-procedure/sentencing-la...
- yelnatz 10y agoHow was it excessive?
- cm2187 10y agoI would say the contrary would be problematic. What if this organisation could publish any dirt on you, could publish your most intimate pictures or details and if you were suing them, they would be fined only $10k, which they wouldn't care about because they make a lot more money abusing people? I would say this would be justice and ordinary citizens being helpless against big business.
- kebolio 10y agoI agree somewhat; the judge still could have bankrupted Gawker without taking too much off the number
- axlee 10y agoI think the damage was not worth putting tens (hundreds?) of people out of a job, most of them who had nothing to do with the Hogan fiasco but are still being punished for it, putting their livelihood in jeopardy for the emotional comfort of a billionaire. The people responsible for the piece should have been personally held responsible.
- jshevek 10y agoRegarding people losing their jobs - that is a result of the terrible judgement and values of the leadership of Gawker. They are not being 'punished' for anything. Do you think that the people at Ford were 'punished' when the leadership of Ford made bad decisions that cost people their jobs? "emotional comfort of a billionaire" That is very dismissive. Are people worth less to you when they have more money?
- qq66 10y ago> Do you think that the people at Ford were 'punished' when the leadership of Ford made bad decisions that cost people their jobs? Yes
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jshevek 10y agoHow can you justify that position? There are consequences to our choices, but they don't always follow a moral principle. If I have two job offers and choose the company that ends up going bankrupt, I'm not being punished. If I'm a farmer and plant according to weather predictions which prove false, losing crops and revenue, that might be bad luck or bad judgement, but its not punishment.
- cm2187 10y agoI am about as worried about gawker employees losing their jobs than I am about ISIS fighters losing their jobs. These guys are making money outing people and publishing sex tapes.
- mhurron 10y agoThe issue I have with it is that money from an external source that had nothing to do with the suit was funnelled in to use it as a weapon. Thiel had an issue with Gawker, Thiel should have taken it to Gawker.
- GVIrish 10y agoWhy have a problem with that? If Gawker was not in the wrong that would've been money wasted. It's not like Hogan/Thiel wore Gawker out by whittling them down with frivolous lawsuits until they couldn't defend themselves anymore.
- mikeyouse 10y agoThat's precisely what Thiel's doing though -- He just hit the jackpot with the Hogan amount. He's also funding several other suits against Gawker including one from someone who claimed to have invented email. He's like a terrible patent troll for journalism. The Gizmodo article that Thiel thinks is worth suing Gawker over: http://gizmodo.com/5887480/the-inventor-of-email-did-not-invent-email http://gizmodo.com/5887480/the-inventor-of-email-did-not-inv...
- GVIrish 10y agoAh ok, that is not something I've seen mentioned anywhere else. Still, Gawker is/was big enough that several frivolous lawsuits would've been unlikely to cause bankruptcy if none of them resulted in an adverse judgment. I have to think Thiel's goal was more to fire multiple shots and hope one finds its mark.
- FireBeyond 10y agoWhat jackpot? They could have gotten the insurance payout. Except they dropped that part of the suit specifically so Gawker could not use the insurance it had purchased for this reason.
- mikeyouse 10y ago
- x0x0 10y agoYeah, pretty much. There is no way Hogan wasn't a public figure. viz him talking to Howard Stern about his sex life. Gawker had, under previous First Amendment jurisprudence, the right to post that tape. Most free speech lawyers assume it will be reversed on appeal. This is completely separate from whether they should have posted that tape.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]