4 ms·
Welcome to the real world of building cars. Some problems just don't appear until cars have been in the hands of owners and out in the wild for a while. And ho
by ams6110 10y ago
Welcome to the real world of building cars. Some problems just don't appear until cars have been in the hands of owners and out in the wild for a while.
And hopefully this should temper some of the enthusiasts claims that because they are electric, the cars are "maintenance free."
We'll likely all be driving electric cars at some point. But Tesla and the other automakers will have to go through a lot of growing pains before we get there.
- mark-r 10y agoThe story isn't about the suspension failures. The story is about the nondisclosure.
- phkahler 10y ago>> The story isn't about the suspension failures. The story is about the nondisclosure. Tesla wouldn't need the nondisclosure agreements if the suspension failures were not story worthy.
- kbenson 10y agoAs other comments here have pointed out, that may be a faulty assumption. If nothing else, an NDA could be construed as an action to prevent an act of goodwill from being presented publicly as a tacit admission of fault. If so, it's fairly ironic that the NDA itself can be presented publicly as a tacit admission of guilt to good effect.
- pbreit 10y agoThey are not maintenance free but avoiding the continuous explosions combustible engines certainly leads to lower maintenance. It's not just wishful thinking.
- bronz 10y agoIt wont temper the claim that EVs are maintenance free because it has nothing to do with how much maintenance EVs require. The premise is that the best implementation of an EV will require much less maintenance than the best implementation of an ICE.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoBut it remains that this argument is a silly one, made by people who've never had brake dust under their fingernails. If you look at common things which need to be fixed/replaced on a five-ten year old car, most of the things are also found on EVs: * Brake pads, lines, discs etc. * Suspension * Steering * Driveline, bushings, bearings * Sensors (a big issue, esp. ABS/ESP sensors) * Electrical wiring * ECU/firmware/software errors * Tires And just a few ICE specifics, which are all on the cheap end compared to the list above: * Exhaust system * Timing belt * Battery * Spark plugs And then there's the EV boogeyman: when will your battery need maintenance, and ultimately replacement? Also, your comment on "the best EV vs the best ICE" is completely besides the point. We could make an ICE vehicle last millions of kilometers without maintenance outside of oil changes etc., but it would be expensive, heavy and bad for the automaker's business. Same arguments apply to EVs. Tesla doesn't profit from having cars that last twenty years with almost no maintenance required.
- bronz 10y agobrakelines dont exist on a tesla. the brakes are electromechanical. the pads and disks last much, much longer because most braking is done with regen. software errors are handled over the air. batteries now last a long time and they will last much, much longer without needing any improvement in technology. the battery in a tesla can be replaced in literally seconds. try that with anything from an ICE that has to be mechanically linked to other parts. you see, you dont really know anything about EVs. but this very simple principle should be enough to settle things: ICEs use many moving parts and use explosions. electric motors have one moving part. so as you can see, the best ICE is worse than the best EV even when you include cost efficiency in the definition of best. EVs are already way better than ICEs. And even if you spent a million dollars making a very reliable ICE it would still be less reliable than a run of the mill EV...
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoThose software errors fixed OTA: do you really imagine Tesla will provide that service for free over the next fifteen-twenty years? Also, you mention no brake lines because of electromechanical brakes: this is not an EV feature. It's a luxury car feature. I'll bet you dollars to doughnuts the Model 3 has a braking system essentially identical to the one on a compact hybrid car. "ICEs use many moving parts and explosions" - this is a stupid argument. Modern ICEs are incredibly reliable. You change the oil and oil filter every year, make sure the coolant level is fine, and you change spark plugs and timing belts twice per decade. None of that is expensive nor difficult, and that engine will keep on ticking for fifty years/hundreds of thousands of miles easily.