2 ms·
Hm, that's an interesting reaction. I also don't really see why that you're getting a negative tone. I don't think the post is suggesting that the work is mea
by klodolph 10y ago
Hm, that's an interesting reaction. I also don't really see why that you're getting a negative tone. I don't think the post is suggesting that the work is meaningless (as your comment interprets) but rather that the meaning of a PhD is mostly not in the thesis itself, but in the ability to conduct independent research, like you said.
- Retric 10y agoIn science original research is only original if you don't know the outcome. There is a huge temptation to assume the outcome matters, but as long as you can validate why you looked into something then the outcome should be meaningless. Thus the thesis matter's, but only up to a point. Otherwise you push people to either make things up, or only reward the lucky. PS: Some non science fields have other criteria, but they are not experimenting.