I actually think a "gamified" feedback system will lead to a bad outcome, especially because it builds a false hope that $random_user with $points > big_number

I actually think a "gamified" feedback system will lead to a bad outcome, especially because it builds a false hope that $random_user with $points > big_number will solve all my problems. A good system would have a few "core people" who work together over a span of years on several successful projects. By a few, I mean 3-7. If we can attract Bunnie Huang, all the better. :)