3 ms·
I can appreciate why you are expressing the negativity you are... but that's not going to help us either. So many years ago, nobody expected anything to take t
by falcolas 10y ago
I can appreciate why you are expressing the negativity you are... but that's not going to help us either.
So many years ago, nobody expected anything to take the place of AOL. Of Yahoo. Of MySpace. Those giants have fallen because someone decided to do something.
So, instead of deciding to do nothing but accept this as inevitable... do something. Contribute to Diaspora. Convince your friends and family to use email instead of Facebook. Explain to others outside of the HN echo chamber why the world we're heading towards is bad, and how to change it.
- dTal 10y agoI didn't see it as negative, or as acceptance of the inevitable. I read "all it takes is a concerted effort and focus and within several hardware generations we can reverse this dire course" and "The day Linux GPL enforcement is a thing is one step closer to curtailing the power abuses by many of these large enterprises over their users because that is actually a straightforward way to do it.". These are good, concrete suggestions and it is extremely unfair to characterise them as "preaching to an echo chamber instead of actually doing something".
- Grishnakh 10y ago>So many years ago, nobody expected anything to take the place of AOL. Of Yahoo. Of MySpace. Those giants have fallen because someone decided to do something. Oh please, this is a terrible comparison. AOL was constantly mocked by general internet users, and finally died simply because it became obsolete thanks to other ISPs, web services like Gmail, etc. All of which are big companies. Yahoo died (it's dead now, but a zombie) because of other big companies, like Google, whose services users migrated to (like Gmail again). MySpace died (again, another zombie) because of the rise of Facebook, which again, is another huge company. Your "someone" who decided to "do something" in every case was a big corporation who out-competed them, not a ragtag bunch of volunteers offering something for free because they want to improve the world. I'd love it if everyone dumped Facebook and switched to Diaspora and email, but I'm sorry, there just aren't any examples at all of this kind of thing happening. Users abandon one crappy corporate service only when some other less-crappy corporate service comes along as an alternative, and the pain of switching becomes low enough to make it worthwhile for them to do so. Highly-technical users are, of course, the exception, but they pretty much never manage to convince their friends and family to abandon the corporate stuff and take up the community-driven stuff, they only succeed (sometimes) in recommending the least-crappy corporate stuff and getting people to switch to that.
- vacri 10y ago> MySpace died (again, another zombie) because of the rise of Facebook, which again, is another huge company. Well... now it's a huge company. It's not like Facebook was a pre-existing massive corporation that decided to pivot and 'do this social media thing'.
- Grishnakh 10y agoFair enough, but they were a profit-seeking company, and a centralized, proprietary one at that. It wasn't some kind of open-source service that you can download and run on your own server that conquered MySpace; it was a company that started small (serving only college students at first) and hired employees and grew.
- gaius 10y agoIf you overlook that they were backed by In-Q-Tel, doesn't get much more massive than that.