4 ms·
> cancer, infectious diseases, global warming, clean energy, access to space... The problems left to solve can be tackled by an increasingly smaller percentag
by adrianN 10y ago
> cancer, infectious diseases, global warming, clean energy, access to space...
The problems left to solve can be tackled by an increasingly smaller percentage of the population. The guys that currently work as taxi drivers or paper pushers can't be reeducated to do cutting edge research.
- thret 10y agoSome of them can be shuffled laterally into equally mundane jobs. I do think we're reaching the point where men with a sub-par IQ may struggle to find work even if they have other excellent qualities.
- hiou 10y agoBut they can still compete on price. Migrant farm labor does that successfully in the present.
- adwf 10y agoThe marginal cost of software is close to zero. You can't compete with free. That's why it's different to the old luddite fallacy. Machinery and robotic factories throughout the ages have cost millions to replace 100's of jobs. Every time you want to build a factory, it costs money. With software that is not necessarily the case. You write it once and then distribute everywhere at little to no cost.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoThe marginal cost of some software is free. Automation requires really understanding the process and formalizing it. It requires knowing all possible failure points, or at least having a "A Bad Thing Has Happened" failure point of last resort and learning the details of those over time. This will annoy people no end. The cost of bad software can be substantial.
- adwf 10y agoGood point, but I'd add that the defining difference that's taking over the software world at the moment is that we're finally working out ways of not needing the programmer to do everything. Machine learning lets the computer learn some things on its own. And it's only getting better.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoI've done some ( very crude ) machine learning , in anger, for money, for some fairly... retro industrial control. Nothing fancy. "machine learning" has a lot of space taken up by fancy filtered "running averages" and other curve fit ... things. Then there are Kalman filters. I can't even categorically say that what I did was or was not a Kalman filter. Once you do that, then there are degenerate and ... overflow cases that propagate like fruit flies. You keep talking about "use cases" in the presence of people for whom that is foreign. The hard part is then accountability. One "thing" can take two smart people who know this stuff well hours to hammer out. Never say never, but because of observer bias and path dependence, it doesn't feel like that gets any better. At some point, a GA has to admit it is powerless in the face of its own inadequacy and ask a grownup what to do. So what you're doing is distilling the set of ... opportunities for difficulty into an increasingly higher proof.
- adwf 10y agoYeah machine learning is no panacea, yet. I tend to classify a lot of learning computer problems as pre- or post-general AI. As in, would it essentially take a human equivalent AI to solve this problem or can we do it sooner with shortcuts and good programming? ie. I used to think that computer vision was completely in this post-AI field, but the recent huge strides that have been made in deep learning etc. have changed my mind considerably. Human-like ability to recognize and differentiate objects is a major step forward in replacing humans around the workplace.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoMigrant farm labor is very physically difficult and skilled. There is a Kevin Costner movie - McFarland - that's a bit sappy but really shows this well.
- Ma8ee 10y agoWe will never run out of problems to solve. When we have cured cancer and made fully autonomous sex dolls there are still stars to explores and deep problems about nature to solve. The problem is that a huge part of the population won't have neither the skills or the inclination to work on hard problems.
- cousin_it 10y agoTell that to 10 postdocs fighting for 1 tenured position.
- Ma8ee 10y agoThat is not a lack of problems, that is a lack of funding.
- cousin_it 10y agoMy point was that it's not a lack of skills and inclination.
- antisthenes 10y agoFor every postdoc out of those 10, there's a 100 graduates fighting for a position and 1000 undergrads fighting for an internship. At any given time slice, skills in a given field are a pyramid. If we assume that the unsolved problems require the highest level of skill to be approached and solved, then there will _always_ be a shortage of problem-solvers (as the problems left become increasingly more difficult and complex) So yes, it is a lack of skills.
- cousin_it 10y agoThere's tons of very simple problems in the world, and tons of people who would be willing to solve them, if only they could get paid for that. That's the limiting factor, not skills.
- 10y ago
- avz 10y agoThis is true and a valid cause for concern. However, it appears to me that some of the problems in research community could actually benefit from an influx of newly trained, moderately-skilled folk. Consider the low interest among scientists in spending time and effort on reproduction of previous results. Project proposal: gather a group of former paper-pushers with Excel experience and train them up in statistics and a scientific discipline (e.g. biochemistry, medicine, astronomy). After 2-3 years of training, take say 20% of the most promising ones and give them a grant to reproduce existing studies. This fixes both the issue of idle workforce and of poor study reproducibility. It could also turn out to be a lot of fun for the affected. Who knows, you may even end up launching a successful scientific career or two. Of course, this would cost money, but hey automation will increase profits which can be taxed and then redirected to these kind of projects.