"ideas are property, they have value, and if a government is going to take your ideas then they by default admit value so there is a taking". I agree with you b

"ideas are property, they have value, and if a government is going to take your ideas then they by default admit value so there is a taking". I agree with you but I think there's a problem that a lawyer may exploit: the goveranment is making them secret not because their monetary value but because they think they could harm national security in some way.