7 ms·
My parents live in a village in Eastern Europe with less than $2 a day (I also chip in to financially help them), and they do indeed raise chickens, they've bei
by paganel 10y ago
My parents live in a village in Eastern Europe with less than $2 a day (I also chip in to financially help them), and they do indeed raise chickens, they've being doing that for the last 15 years or so, since they moved out to the countryside.
Bill Gates is correct in his assessment, it's way more profitable to raise chickens than, say, cows. You need to have a bigger barn for cows, you need to do all the hay thing, which is very time consuming and demands a lot of extra work just for feeding said cows, you need to pay someone to take care of the cows when they go out to eat in the summer on the communal field. It's easier to just barter your chickens' eggs for some milk or cheese, that's at least what my mom does.
It's also quite profitable to grow beans and cabbage. They preserve well over winter well into spring and you can also use them for bartering.
- Houshalter 10y ago> it's way more profitable to raise chickens than, say, cows. You need to have a bigger barn for cows, you need to do all the hay thing, which is very time consuming and demands a lot of extra work just for feeding said cows, you need to pay someone to take care of the cows when they go out to eat in the summer on the communal field. This is surprising to me. Of course a cow should be more work to raise than a chicken. But it has so many times more meat on it than a chicken, and is more energy efficient per calorie consumed too. Similarly with beans and cabbage. They might be easier to grow, but in terms of calories they seem much less efficient than, say, potatoes. If this was addressed in the article, sorry. It's just a blank page on my browser.
- thevardanian 10y agoI highly doubt that Beef is a more efficient if source of meat than Chicken. I think Chicken meat is a lot more efficient. A little quick googling and I found: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feed_conversion_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feed_conversion_ratio
- Houshalter 10y agoWhy would you think that? Larger animals are usually much more energy efficient for various reasons - less surface area to radiate heat, and economies of scale with larger organs.
- ane 10y agoNo, beef and lamb are the most energy consuming sources of meat. (A dairy producing cow is different.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feed_conversion_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feed_conversion_ratio For cattle, a FCR range from less than 5 to more than 20 kg feed dry matter per kg gain may be encountered.[ Whereas for chickens: Poultry has a feed conversion ratio of 2 to 1.
- baddox 10y agoAgain, that's simple mass efficiency. We can also talk about other efficiencies, like cost of feed versus cost of meat.
- Houshalter 10y agoI believe you, but I'm very surprised. That has larger animals almost universally less efficient than smaller animals, which is the exact opposite of the expected efficiency due to Kleiber's law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kleiber%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kleiber%27s_law >a cat, having a mass 100 times that of a mouse, will have a metabolism roughly 32 times greater than that of a mouse. And yet this is saying that a mice sized animal should be expected to have the same, or perhaps even better Feed conversion ratio than a cat sized animal. Again, I believe you, but it makes no sense.
- mapt 10y agoThe larger livestock will usually have a much longer lifespan. It has to keep its flesh heated above ambient for that entire lifespan. If Mouse A lives 100x longer and puts on the same weight and achieves the same stature as Mouse B, it's spent ~100x as much energy getting to the same physiological place as Mouse B.
- paganel 10y ago> They might be easier to grow, but in terms of calories they seem much less efficient than, say, potatoes I agree about potatoes, but that only works for relatively cooler climates, i.e. places like Poland or Ireland. It can easily get to 35-37 degrees Celsius in the summer at the place where my parents live (not to mention places like the Indian subcontinent or Africa), at which point storing potatoes becomes a challenge. > But it has so many times more meat on it than a chicken, and is more energy efficient per calorie consumed too. It's all about the return on investment. Raising cows only becomes financially viable once you pass a certain number threshold (meaning big farms), otherwise you're pretty much doing voluntary work. It's a lot of work in order to feed a cow, I mean, lots and lots of work, and said work is pretty effective in burning calories. A lot of farmers in the European Union who are in the cow-raising business (I'd say most) wouldn't make it without financial help from the EU and from their governments. I'd say that goats are a lot better option if you really need meat. They feed practically on everything (cows are a lot more picky) and they're smaller, so they're easier to "store" and protect at night. This is why I think they're so widespread in the poorer regions of the world.
- bromuro 10y ago> I agree about potatoes, but that only works for relatively cooler climates, i.e. places like Poland or Ireland. It can easily get to 35-37 degrees Celsius in the summer at the place where my parents live (not to mention places like the Indian subcontinent or Africa), at which point storing potatoes becomes a challenge. Is it? Here in South Italy we successfully grow potatoes and we have such hot summers.
- pm 10y agoJudging from the parent comment, I don't think growing potatoes is the problem, but storing them.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe classic solution to storing potatoes is the root cellar: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Root_cellar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Root_cellar In the US they were used to keep vegetables warmer in the winter (while below household temps), but they should also work for cooling.
- developer2 10y agoI'm going to provide an entirely uneducated guess regarding cows. I would bet that the average person without any training or resources is capable of raising chickens, whereas the average person would have their cows die before maturing. I'm not commenting on the "average African". I'm talking about my own first-world Caucasian self. I bet you I could raise chickens with very few resources. I also bet I couldn't do the same with cows, which seem to be resource hogs and in need of more maintenance. It's like having a dog vs. a cat as a pet. A cat just needs to be fed and given a box where they can place their waste. A dog needs to be walked, socialized with other dogs, etc. Do you need to travel for a 2-day weekend? With a cat, while not ideal, you can get away with leaving behind plenty of food and water along with an extra litter box. You simply cannot abandon a dog on its own for 2 days.
- rsync 10y ago"I'm going to provide an entirely uneducated guess regarding cows. I would bet that the average person without any training or resources is capable of raising chickens, whereas the average person would have their cows die before maturing. I'm not commenting on the "average African". I'm talking about my own first-world Caucasian self. I bet you I could raise chickens with very few resources" Your instincts are incorrect - at least in a rural, or semi rural setting. Your chickens may be very safe and easy to raise in an urban environment that is free of small and medium sized predators, but outside of that environment there are many, many things that will very quickly dispose of all of your chickens - sometimes in just one night. Raccoons, weasels, foxes, coyotes, large birds (vultures, hawks, owls), bobcats ... In our rural area (west marin county, california) we need to be on our A game to keep the chickens alive ... raccoon traps set, elevated coop, hens locked up nightly, wings clipped so they can't get out of the run, high fence, three hot electric wires, etc., etc. A cow on the other hand is too big for most of those animals (a hawk can't carry away a calf) and the mother (and other mothers) are nearby. They're big.
- x0x0 10y agoOTOH, hay is hard to make and expensive to store, because you absolutely cannot let it get wet. If it even becomes damp it can give cows the heaves (and will give horses), and it can give farmers farmer's lung. Plus an untimely rain after you cut it can ruin a growing season's entire yield. If you get it wet, you'll burn your barn down because it composts.
- justhw 10y agoDisable Ghostery (white-list the site) if you're seeing a blank page. It fixed it for me.
- exolymph 10y agoWhitelisting every site disabled by Ghostery (or whatever tracker-blocker someone uses) kinda defeats the purpose of having it in the first place.
- stinkytaco 10y agoIn addition to the other points people have made, with beef you have the problem of preservation. Unless you coordinate so everyone slaughters their cows at a different time and you can share the meat (which presents problems as well), you end up with a glut of meat for a short period of time, rather than the continuing output of a chicken.
- goshx 10y agoIt is important to remember that if you kill a chicken, you can consume it entirely in the same day with no need for refrigeration and electricity. Also, chickens reproduce, grow faster and lay eggs that you can also consume. I grew up in my grandma's backyard (literally) with chickens, cows and porks. Cows were mostly used for milk than meat.
- Hyperborian 10y ago> ...and is more energy efficient per calorie consumed too. I've read studies in the past that found entirely the opposite, and by a very large margin. If I remember correctly, I believe that raising chickens for meat was many times more efficient, and among common meat livestock cows were the worst. Are you sure you've got it right?
- herdrick 10y agoCows can graze and put on weight on land that practically nothing other than deer can survive on. Think of the sagebrush semi-arid land of the American Great Basin (ex. northern Nevada, eastern Oregon). Chickens and goats can't.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sampo 10y ago> Of course a cow should be more work to raise than a chicken. But it has so many times more meat on it than a chicken, and is more energy efficient per calorie consumed too. Wikipedia says quite the opposite: "Two kilograms of grain must be fed to poultry to produce 1 kg of weight gain, much less than that required for pork or beef." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poultry_farming#Efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poultry_farming#Efficiency
- dagw 10y agoIs the ratio of edible-calories-to-body-weight roughly the same chickens and cows?
- puranjay 10y agoRaising cows for meat is not an option in a very large part of the developing world - India - because of religious reasons. (And it is also illegal in most of the states here in India)
- csomar 10y agoI think it relates to risk, growth and capital. You only need $10-20 to get started with chickens, and from there you can grow quickly to $500-1000 in a matter of few months. To get started with a cow, you'll need a huge capital (thousands) and take a big risk (cow dies).
- pajaroide 10y agoThis a list of edible protein that can be grown per unit of land, soybeans and other legumes top the list along with hemp seeds, animal sources are the less efficient. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edible_protein_per_unit_area_of_land?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edible_protein_per_unit_area_o...
- personjerry 10y agoAs a bonus, chicken meat is also usually considered healthier :D
- MustardTiger 10y ago>it's way more profitable to raise chickens than, say, cows But you are pretty much comparing to the worst possible option there with cattle. Almost everything else is easier and has a better feed conversion ratio: chickens, turkeys, ducks, rabbits, pigs, goats, sheep, etc.
- rconti 10y agoThis immediately makes me think that, as the supply of chickens goes up, their value goes down. You won't be able to sell a chicken for $5 anymore if everybody has enough. But the point is taken that they produce a lot of food for how little upkeep they require.
- mhink 10y agoOn the other hand, they also have a pretty clear floor on their sale value, because if the price drops too low, the farmer could just eat the meat/eggs themselves.
- jegoodwin3 10y agoYou might think so, but the Commerce clause has been interpreted to mean that raising food for your own consumption is restraint of trade between the several states: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn "An Ohio farmer, Roscoe Filburn, was growing wheat for use to feed animals on his own farm. The U.S. government had established limits on wheat production based on acreage owned by a farmer, in order to stabilize wheat prices and supplies. In 1941 Filburn grew more than the limits permitted and he was ordered to pay a penalty of $117.11. " After all, that food you raised for yourself prevented you from needing to buy food from another state, and so, well....
- massysett 10y agoThere is no Commerce Clause in Africa.
- fit2rule 10y agoYet.
- dgacmu 10y agoTo be more clear: The commerce clause was interpreted such as to allow the federal government to impose limits on agricultural production even when the food is being used to feed your own animals. We already have numerous such restrictions (e.g., brewing beer). A key point in this, in fact, was that it doesn't matter if it's being produced for your own (animals) consumption vs. for sale. But that has nothing to do with whether the pure act of raising your own food is restraint of trade, absent restrictions on production. If you were raising the food in a way that it was legal to sell it, you're raising it in a way that's legal for your own animals to eat as well.
- hugh4 10y ago>You need to have a bigger barn for cows, you need to do all the hay thing, which is very time consuming and demands a lot of extra work just for feeding said cows, you need to pay someone to take care of the cows when they go out to eat in the summer on the communal field Depends where you are, of course. Some places you just leave your cows out eating grass for years until it's time to slaughter them, then you hire some dudes with helicopters to round 'em all up. And a barn? For 150,000 cows?
- creshal 10y agoThat only works in places like the US or Australia, where land is cheap and safe. In Europe you wouldn't find enough land for that, and in many other places you couldn't keep cows unsupervised for a day.
- nibnib 10y agoThe context is 2$/day, it's not exactly fair to suggest people hire some dudes with helicopters.
- oh_sigh 10y agoWhat country in europe? Are they $2/day because they don't have jobs, or because they work but they only make $2/day?
- paganel 10y agoThe poorer parts of Romania. > Are they $2/day because they don't have jobs, or because they work but they only make $2 It was, let's say difficult, for them to find a steady job in their early 50s after the steel works factory that was feeding my hometown and where they had worked for almost all their life closed down. They had to sell the city apartment (because bills have a nasty habit of showing up at your door each and every month) and moved out to the country-house, where at least they were able to put some food on their table. I shared these personal details because I think that my parents' story happened to a lot of people in Eastern Europe in the '90s-early 2000s (Russia saw its average life expectancy actually go down in the '90s), I'm talking about people who fell hard through the social safety net's very large holes. Things are better now, of course, but there are entire generations who saw their entire life's work go to nothing. I think a similar thing is now happening in places like Greece.