3 ms·
By saying consciousness is a pattern in the flux of matter, you are echoing my point that consciousness can't be based on the particular matter. So, if you the
by yters 19y ago
By saying consciousness is a pattern in the flux of matter, you are echoing my point that consciousness can't be based on the particular matter. So, if you then think consciousness is the pattern, shouldn't two instantiations of the same pattern be the same consciousness?
Sorry we're going in circles here, but I do not understand your jump in logic. We aren't talking about identity in terms of how to pick a particular consciousness out of a set. We're talking about the subjective experience of "I", and I have a hard time seeing how any of those identifiers give me my sense of continuity.
It is also completely impossible for me to consider the "I" to be an illusion, because I am involved in the very act of trying to escape myself. It is just as incoherent as saying there is no truth, or the law of non contradiction doesn't hold. You can tell yourself such things if you want, but you can't do so in an intellectually honest way, since intellectual honesty presupposes these concepts.
- ericb 19y ago>>shouldn't two instantiations of the same pattern be the same consciousness? No--they will never occupy the same coordinates as each other in time and space, and therefore can't be the same consciousness, by definition. The "I" doesn't have to be entirely an illusion, but our understanding of can be wrong. I didn't used to like dark chocolate. Now I do. Which "version" is the real me, the one who doesn't like dark chocolate, or the one who does?
- yters 19y agoI'd say you are the person that underlies the change. Anyways, this is the contentious point, whether there is an experiencer having experiences, or whether there are just experiences. We've already circled around this point a couple times, so I don't think the discussion will move forward anymore.
- ericb 19y agoYeah. Time of death, 8:48 EST Tuesday. Good chat, though.