3 ms·
The visual quality is a bit of a red herring, as in most situations you'd just up the bitrate until it was acceptable. So quality and bitrate are in some senses
by ZeroGravitas 10y ago
The visual quality is a bit of a red herring, as in most situations you'd just up the bitrate until it was acceptable. So quality and bitrate are in some senses interchangeable.
The graph above the comparison suggests that at this low bitrate, HEVC/BGP will very slightly outperform Daala on average, but each individual image may be slightly better or worse. It'll more probably come down to which kinds of artifact you're more familiar with and so see more easily.
Switching quickly between the original and the encoded version is probably the easiest way to spot the artifacts/compromises that are being made.
- jmvalin 10y agoObviously, the rates for these images are the same across all codecs. Choosing the rate for such comparison is also a little tricky. If you choose a rate that people would use to make their image look really good (which how most people compress images), then you have a realistic use case, but nobody can see much difference. If you choose too low a rate, then all images look really ugly. So I tried picking a rate where the resulting images are tolerable, but low enough that differences across codecs are easily noticeable.